Kruse Michael I, Baas-Sylvester Katie, Wildeman Vanessa, Clarizio Alexandra, Upadhye Suneel, Bigham Blair L
Department of Family Medicine, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada.
McMaster University Michael D. DeGroote School of Medicine, Hamilton, ON, Canada.
CJEM. 2025 Jan;27(1):32-37. doi: 10.1007/s43678-024-00797-y. Epub 2025 Jan 10.
Intersex people make up 1.7-4% of the population of North America. A recent scoping review of emergency department (ED) relevant literature for the care of sexual and gender minorities found almost no representation of this population. Intersex people have unique equity, diversity, and inclusion needs in the ED, so we undertook a review of international guidelines to identify ED-relevant recommendations.
Using the PRISMA criteria, we systematically searched OVID Medline, EMBASE, CINAHL, and the gray literature for any clinical practice guideline (CPG) or best practice statement (BPS) published until Oct 21, 2022. We included articles in English, which included care of intersex people of any age, in any setting, region, or nation, and were of national or international in scope. We excluded primary research, systematic or narrative reviews, non-CPS or BPS statements, editorials, articles of regional or individual hospital scope, or if a more recent version had been published. Recommendations relevant to the ED were identified and the guideline and recommendations scored for quality using the AGREE-II and AGREE-REX tools respectively.
Of 1599 studies identified, 1400 studies were excluded, 199 full-text reviews completed, and 95 studies included for evaluation. There were no ED-relevant recommendations found among these guideline documents.
A systematic review of the literature for ED-relevant guidelines for the care of Intersex populations returned no results. Given the risk of increasing barriers to care for intersex people, and the increasing use of the ED for primary care, the requirements of Intersex people need to be investigated and integrated into future development of a CPG for care of sexual and gender minority populations in the ED.
间性人占北美人口的1.7%-4%。最近一项针对急诊科(ED)相关文献中有关性少数群体和性别少数群体护理的范围界定性综述发现,几乎没有该群体的相关内容。间性人在急诊科有独特的公平、多样性和包容性需求,因此我们对国际指南进行了综述,以确定与急诊科相关的建议。
我们使用PRISMA标准,系统地检索了OVID Medline、EMBASE、CINAHL以及灰色文献,以查找截至2022年10月21日发布的任何临床实践指南(CPG)或最佳实践声明(BPS)。我们纳入了英文文章,这些文章涵盖任何年龄、任何环境、地区或国家的间性人护理,且范围为国家或国际层面。我们排除了原始研究、系统综述或叙述性综述、非CPG或BPS声明、社论、地区或单个医院范围的文章,或者如果已发表更新版本的文章。确定了与急诊科相关的建议,并分别使用AGREE-II和AGREE-REX工具对指南和建议的质量进行评分。
在识别出的1599项研究中,排除了1400项研究,完成了199项全文综述,95项研究纳入评估。在这些指南文件中未发现与急诊科相关的建议。
对有关间性人群体护理的急诊科相关指南的文献进行系统综述未得到结果。鉴于间性人获得护理的障碍可能增加,且急诊科用于初级护理的情况日益增多,需要对间性人的需求进行调查,并将其纳入未来急诊科性少数群体和性别少数群体护理临床实践指南的制定中。