Mellal Amine, González-López Pablo, Giammattei Lorenzo, George Mercy, Starnoni Daniele, Cossu Giulia, Cornelius Jan Frederick, Berhouma Moncef, Messerer Mahmoud, Daniel Roy Thomas
Department of Neurosurgery, University Hospital of Lausanne and University of Lausanne, 1011, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Department of Neurosurgery, General University Hospital Alicante and University of Alicante, Spain.
Brain Spine. 2024 Dec 12;5:104163. doi: 10.1016/j.bas.2024.104163. eCollection 2025.
While cadaveric dissections remain the cornerstone of education in skull base surgery, they are associated with high costs, difficulty acquiring specimens, and a lack of pathology in anatomical samples. This study evaluated the impact of a hand-crafted three-dimensional (3D)-printed head model and virtual reality (VR) in enhancing skull base surgery training.
How effective are 3D-printed models and VR in enhancing training in skull base surgery?
A two-day skull base training course was conducted with 12 neurosurgical trainees and 11 faculty members. The course used a 3D-printed head model, VR simulations, and cadaveric dissections. The 3D model included four tumors and was manually assembled to replicate tumor-modified neuroanatomy. Trainees performed surgical approaches, with pre- and post-course self-assessments to evaluate their knowledge and skills. Faculty provided feedback on the model's educational value and accuracy. All items were rated on a 5-point scale.
Trainees showed significant improvement in understanding spatial relationships and surgical steps, with scores increasing from 3.40 ± 0.70 to 4.50 ± 0.53 for both items. Faculty rated the educational value of the model with a score of 4.33 ± 0.82, and a score of 5.00 ± 0.00 for recommending the 3D-printed model to other residents. However, realism in soft tissue simulations received lower ratings.
Virtual reality and 3D-printed models enhance anatomical understanding and surgical training in skull base surgery. These tools offer a cost-effective, realistic, and accessible alternative to cadaveric training, though further refinement in soft tissue realism is needed.
虽然尸体解剖仍然是颅底外科手术教育的基石,但它们存在成本高昂、获取标本困难以及解剖样本缺乏病理学特征等问题。本研究评估了手工制作的三维(3D)打印头部模型和虚拟现实(VR)在加强颅底外科手术培训方面的影响。
3D打印模型和VR在加强颅底外科手术培训方面的效果如何?
为12名神经外科实习生和11名教员举办了为期两天的颅底培训课程。该课程使用了3D打印头部模型、VR模拟和尸体解剖。3D模型包括四个肿瘤,并通过手工组装以复制肿瘤改变的神经解剖结构。实习生进行手术操作,并在课程前后进行自我评估,以评估他们的知识和技能。教员对模型的教育价值和准确性提供反馈。所有项目均采用5分制评分。
实习生在理解空间关系和手术步骤方面有显著提高,这两个项目的得分从3.40±0.70提高到4.50±0.53。教员对模型的教育价值评分为4.33±0.82,将3D打印模型推荐给其他住院医师的评分为5.00±0.00。然而,软组织模拟的真实感得分较低。
虚拟现实和3D打印模型可加强颅底外科手术中的解剖学理解和手术培训。这些工具为尸体培训提供了一种经济高效、逼真且易于使用的替代方案,不过软组织真实感方面还需要进一步改进。