Suppr超能文献

女性真的(并非)比男性更健谈吗?关于日常词汇使用中二元性别异同的预注册报告。

Are women really (not) more talkative than men? A registered report of binary gender similarities/differences in daily word use.

作者信息

Tidwell Colin A, Danvers Alexander F, Pfeifer Valeria A, Abel Danielle B, Alisic Eva, Beer Andrew, Bierstetel Sabrina J, Bollich-Ziegler Kathryn L, Bruni Michelle, Calabrese William R, Chiarello Christine, Demiray Burcu, Dimidjian Sona, Fingerman Karen L, Haas Maximilian, Kaplan Deanna M, Kim Yijung K, Knezevic Goran, Lazarevic Ljiljana B, Luo Minxia, Macbeth Alessandra, Manson Joseph H, Mascaro Jennifer S, Metcalf Christina, Minor Kyle S, Moseley Suzanne, Polsinelli Angelina J, Raison Charles L, Rilling James K, Robbins Megan L, Sbarra David, Slatcher Richard B, Sun Jessie, Vasileva Mira, Vazire Simine, Mehl Matthias R

机构信息

Department of Psychology, University of Arizona.

Sierra Tucson.

出版信息

J Pers Soc Psychol. 2025 Feb;128(2):367-391. doi: 10.1037/pspp0000534. Epub 2025 Jan 13.

Abstract

Women are widely assumed to be more talkative than men. Challenging this assumption, Mehl et al. (2007) provided empirical evidence that men and women do not differ significantly in their daily word use, speaking about 16,000 words per day (WPD) each. However, concerns were raised that their sample was too small to yield generalizable estimates and too age and context homogeneous to permit inferences beyond college students. This registered report replicated and extended the previous study of binary gender differences in daily word use to address these concerns. Across 2,197 participants (more than five-fold the original sample size), pooled over 22 samples (631,030 ambient audio recordings), men spoke on average 11,950 WPD and women 13,349 WPD, with very large individual differences (< 100 to > 120,000 WPD). The estimated gender difference (1,073 WPD; = 0.13; 95% CrI [316, 1,824]) was about twice as large as in the original study. Smaller differences emerged among adolescent (513 WPD), emerging adult (841 WPD), and older adult (-788 WPD) participants, but a substantially larger difference emerged for participants in early and middle adulthood (3,275 WPD; = 0.32). Despite the considerable sample size(s), all estimates carried large statistical uncertainty and, except for the gender difference in early and middle adulthood, provide inconclusive evidence regarding whether the two genders ultimately speak a practically equivalent number of WPD, based on the preregistered ± 1,000 WPD regions of practical equivalence criterion. Experienced stress had no meaningful effect on the gender difference, and no clear pattern emerged as to whether the gender difference is accentuated for subjectively rated compared with objectively observed talkativeness. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2025 APA, all rights reserved).

摘要

人们普遍认为女性比男性更健谈。为了挑战这一假设,梅尔等人(2007年)提供了实证证据,表明男性和女性在日常词汇使用上没有显著差异,每人每天大约说16000个单词(WPD)。然而,有人担心他们的样本太小,无法得出可推广的估计值,而且年龄和背景过于单一,无法进行超出大学生范围的推断。这份注册报告重复并扩展了先前关于日常词汇使用中二元性别差异的研究,以解决这些问题。在2197名参与者(样本量是原始样本的五倍多)中,汇总了22个样本(631030次环境音频记录),男性平均每天说11950个WPD,女性平均每天说13349个WPD,个体差异非常大(<100至>120000个WPD)。估计的性别差异(1073个WPD;效应量 = 0.13;95%可信区间[316, 1824])约为原始研究的两倍。在青少年(513个WPD)、新兴成年人(841个WPD)和老年人(-788个WPD)参与者中出现的差异较小,但在成年早期和中期参与者中出现的差异要大得多(3275个WPD;效应量 = 0.32)。尽管样本量相当大,但所有估计都存在很大的统计不确定性,除了成年早期和中期的性别差异外,根据预先注册的±1000个WPD的实际等效标准区域,关于两性最终实际说的WPD数量是否大致相等,提供的证据并不确凿。经历的压力对性别差异没有显著影响,而且对于主观评定的健谈程度与客观观察到的健谈程度相比,性别差异是否会加剧,没有出现明确的模式。(PsycInfo数据库记录(c)2025美国心理学会,保留所有权利)

相似文献

3
Are women really more talkative than men?女性真的比男性更健谈吗?
Science. 2007 Jul 6;317(5834):82. doi: 10.1126/science.1139940.

本文引用的文献

2
Are many sex/gender differences really power differences?许多性别差异真的是权力差异吗?
PNAS Nexus. 2024 Feb 27;3(2):pgae025. doi: 10.1093/pnasnexus/pgae025. eCollection 2024 Feb.
10
Recommendations for Increasing the Transparency of Analysis of Preexisting Data Sets.提高现有数据集分析透明度的建议。
Adv Methods Pract Psychol Sci. 2019 Sep;2(3):214-227. doi: 10.1177/2515245919848684. Epub 2019 Jun 11.

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验