Savaria Virginie, Queenton Johanne, Carrier Annie
Université de Sherbrooke, Sherbrooke, QC, Canada.
Centre de recherche sur le vieillissement, Sherbrooke, QC, Canada.
JMIR Res Protoc. 2025 Jan 17;14:e58271. doi: 10.2196/58271.
The centralization of decision-making power in the public health care system has a negative impact on the practice of professionals and the quality of home care services (HCS) for seniors. To improve HCS, decentralized management could be a particularly promising approach. To be effective, strategies designed to incorporate this management approach require attention to 3 elements: autonomy of local stakeholders, individual and organizational capacities, and accountability for actions and decisions. Not many studies have focused on strategies for integrating decentralized and collaborative management at the local level in HCS.
The overall aim of this study is to coconstruct HCS management strategies and explore decentralized practices in the day-to-day work of low-level managers and professionals. The specific objectives, in collaboration with local HCS stakeholders, are to (1) identify concrete and achievable strategies for decentralized management, and (2) describe factors (facilitators and obstacles) that could potentially influence their integration.
This participatory action research involves a cyclical process. Before initiating the cycles, a preliminary stage consists of forming a steering committee composed of managers (n=3), professionals (n=3), seniors (n=3), informal caregivers (n=3), and the research team (n=3). This committee will facilitate multistakeholder consultation to coconstruct local management strategies based on a real-life problem identified by the committee. The steering committee will also guide the research process. The first cycle will consist of establishing an initial plan of decentralized management strategies. During the observation phase, meetings of 4 homogeneous focus groups, including managers, professionals, seniors, and informal caregivers, will be held. During the reflection phase, a thematic analysis will be carried out, and data will be interpreted and validated by the steering committee. Then, in the action phase, results will be presented to managers and professionals so that they can coconstruct a plan of decentralized management strategies to prioritize. The second cycle will explore the factors involved. The observation, reflection, and action phases will be repeated. Ultimately, the results of the 2 cycles will be integrated in a model coconstructed by the steering committee.
Data collection is in progress; the partnership officially began on February 1, 2024, and the plan is to continue data collection through 2025. The steering committee will validate the data to ensure that they are accurate and that the results reflect the reality of local stakeholders.
By identifying decentralized and collaborative management strategies at the local level as well as factors to facilitate their integration in HCS, this approach can be used for other decentralized management projects in different areas of the health care system. This study will give decision makers insight into strategies aimed at improving the management of their institution, which will enhance seniors' well-being and the quality of their health care services.
INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT IDENTIFIER (IRRID): DERR1-10.2196/58271.
公共卫生保健系统中决策权的集中对专业人员的实践以及老年人家庭护理服务(HCS)的质量产生负面影响。为改善家庭护理服务,分权管理可能是一种特别有前景的方法。要想有效,旨在纳入这种管理方法的策略需要关注三个要素:地方利益相关者的自主权、个人和组织能力以及对行动和决策的问责制。没有多少研究关注在家庭护理服务地方层面整合分权与协作管理的策略。
本研究的总体目标是共同构建家庭护理服务管理策略,并探索基层管理人员和专业人员日常工作中的分权实践。与地方家庭护理服务利益相关者合作的具体目标是:(1)确定分权管理的具体且可实现的策略;(2)描述可能影响这些策略整合的因素(促进因素和障碍)。
这项参与式行动研究涉及一个循环过程。在启动循环之前,初步阶段包括组建一个指导委员会,成员包括管理人员(3名)、专业人员(3名)、老年人(3名)、非正式护理人员(3名)和研究团队(3名)。该委员会将促进多利益相关者协商,根据委员会确定的现实问题共同构建地方管理策略。指导委员会还将指导研究过程。第一个循环将包括制定分权管理策略的初始计划。在观察阶段,将举行4个同类焦点小组会议,成员包括管理人员、专业人员、老年人和非正式护理人员。在反思阶段,将进行主题分析,数据将由指导委员会进行解读和验证。然后,在行动阶段,将结果呈现给管理人员和专业人员,以便他们共同构建一个优先排序的分权管理策略计划。第二个循环将探索其中涉及的因素。观察、反思和行动阶段将重复进行。最终,两个循环的结果将整合到指导委员会共同构建的一个模型中。
数据收集正在进行;合作于2024年2月1日正式开始,计划持续收集数据至2025年。指导委员会将验证数据,以确保其准确性,且结果反映地方利益相关者的实际情况。
通过确定地方层面的分权与协作管理策略以及促进其在家庭护理服务中整合的因素,这种方法可用于医疗保健系统不同领域的其他分权管理项目。本研究将使决策者深入了解旨在改善其机构管理的策略,这将提高老年人的福祉及其医疗保健服务的质量。
国际注册报告识别号(IRRID):DERR1-10.2196/58271。