Yoganathan S A, Torfeh Tarraf, Paloor Satheesh, Hammoud Rabih, Al-Hammadi Noora, Zhang Rui
Department of Radiation Oncology, Hamad Medical Corporation, Doha, Qatar.
Department of Radiation Oncology, Saint John Regional Hospital, Horizon Health Network, Saint John, New Brunswick, Canada.
Biomed Phys Eng Express. 2025 Jan 17;11(2). doi: 10.1088/2057-1976/ada6ba.
This study aimed to develop and evaluate an efficient method to automatically segment T1- and T2-weighted brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) images. We specifically compared the segmentation performance of individual convolutional neural network (CNN) models against an ensemble approach to advance the accuracy of MRI-guided radiotherapy (RT) planning.. The evaluation was conducted on a private clinical dataset and a publicly available dataset (HaN-Seg). Anonymized MRI data from 55 brain cancer patients, including T1-weighted, T1-weighted with contrast, and T2-weighted images, were used in the clinical dataset. We employed an EDL strategy that integrated five independently trained 2D neural networks, each tailored for precise segmentation of tumors and organs at risk (OARs) in the MRI scans. Class probabilities were obtained by averaging the final layer activations (Softmax outputs) from the five networks using a weighted-average method, which were then converted into discrete labels. Segmentation performance was evaluated using the Dice similarity coefficient (DSC) and Hausdorff distance at 95% (HD95). The EDL model was also tested on the HaN-Seg public dataset for comparison.. The EDL model demonstrated superior segmentation performance on both the clinical and public datasets. For the clinical dataset, the ensemble approach achieved an average DSC of 0.7 ± 0.2 and HD95 of 4.5 ± 2.5 mm across all segmentations, significantly outperforming individual networks which yielded DSC values ≤0.6 and HD95 values ≥14 mm. Similar improvements were observed in the HaN-Seg public dataset.. Our study shows that the EDL model consistently outperforms individual CNN networks in both clinical and public datasets, demonstrating the potential of ensemble learning to enhance segmentation accuracy. These findings underscore the value of the EDL approach for clinical applications, particularly in MRI-guided RT planning.
本研究旨在开发并评估一种自动分割T1加权和T2加权脑磁共振成像(MRI)图像的有效方法。我们特别比较了单个卷积神经网络(CNN)模型与集成方法的分割性能,以提高MRI引导放射治疗(RT)计划的准确性。评估是在一个私人临床数据集和一个公开可用数据集(HaN-Seg)上进行的。临床数据集中使用了55例脑癌患者的匿名MRI数据,包括T1加权、T1加权增强和T2加权图像。我们采用了一种集成深度学习(EDL)策略,该策略整合了五个独立训练的二维神经网络,每个网络都针对MRI扫描中的肿瘤和危及器官(OAR)的精确分割进行了定制。通过使用加权平均方法对五个网络的最终层激活(Softmax输出)进行平均来获得类别概率,然后将其转换为离散标签。使用Dice相似系数(DSC)和95% Hausdorff距离(HD95)评估分割性能。EDL模型也在HaN-Seg公共数据集上进行了测试以作比较。EDL模型在临床和公共数据集上均表现出卓越的分割性能。对于临床数据集,集成方法在所有分割中实现的平均DSC为0.7±0.2,HD95为4.5±2.5毫米,显著优于单个网络,单个网络产生的DSC值≤0.6且HD95值≥14毫米。在HaN-Seg公共数据集中也观察到了类似的改进。我们的研究表明,EDL模型在临床和公共数据集中始终优于单个CNN网络,证明了集成学习在提高分割准确性方面的潜力。这些发现强调了EDL方法在临床应用中的价值,特别是在MRI引导的RT计划中。