Konings A W, Ruifrok A C
Radiat Res. 1985 Apr;102(1):86-98.
The role of membrane lipids and membrane fluidity in thermosensitivity of mammalian cells is not well understood. The limited experimental data in the literature have led to conflicting results. A detailed investigation of lipid composition and membrane fluidity of cellular membranes was undertaken to determine their relationship to cell survival after hyperthermia. Ehrlich ascites (EA) cells, mouse fibroblast LM cells, and HeLa S3 cells differed in thermosensitivity as expressed by a D0 of 3.1, 5.2, and 9.7 min, respectively, at 44 degrees C. No correlation with cellular thermosensitivity could be found with respect to the amount of cholesterol and to the cholesterol to phospholipid ratio in the particulate fraction of the cells. By growing the cells for some generations in different media, cholesterol and phospholipid content could be changed in the particulate fraction, but no difference in cell survival was observed. When mouse fibroblasts were grown for 24 hr in a serum-free medium supplemented with arachidonic acid (20:4), all subcellular membranes were about eight times richer in phospholipids containing polyunsaturated acyl (PUFA) chains and membrane fluidity was increased as measured by fluorescence polarization of diphenylhexatriene (DPH). The alterations resulted in a higher thermosensitivity. When mouse fibroblasts were made thermotolerant no change in cholesterol and phospholipid content could be found in the particulate fraction of the cells. The relative weights and the quality of the phospholipids as well as the fatty acid composition of the phospholipids appeared to be the same for normal and thermotolerant cells. Fluidity measurements in whole cells, isolated plasma membranes, and liposomes prepared from phospholipids extracted from the cells revealed no significant differences between normal and thermotolerant fibroblasts when assayed by fluorescence polarization (DPH) and electron spin resonance (5-nitroxystearate). It is concluded that the mechanism of thermal adaptation resulting in differences in lipid composition as reported in the literature differs from the mechanism of the acquisition of thermal tolerance. The lower heat sensitivity of thermotolerant cells, as initiated by a nonlethal triggering heat dose followed by an induction period at 37 degrees C, does not involve changes in lipid composition and membrane fluidity. However, a prompt and clear (also nonlethal) change in membrane fluidity by an increase in PUFA does result in an increased thermosensitivity, probably because of an indirect effect via the lipids in causing disfunctioning of proteins in the membrane and/or the cytoskeleton.
膜脂和膜流动性在哺乳动物细胞热敏感性中的作用尚未得到充分理解。文献中有限的实验数据导致了相互矛盾的结果。我们对细胞膜的脂质组成和膜流动性进行了详细研究,以确定它们与热疗后细胞存活的关系。艾氏腹水(EA)细胞、小鼠成纤维细胞LM细胞和HeLa S3细胞的热敏感性不同,在44℃时,它们的D0分别为3.1、5.2和9.7分钟。就细胞颗粒部分中胆固醇的含量以及胆固醇与磷脂的比例而言,未发现与细胞热敏感性存在相关性。通过在不同培养基中培养细胞几代,可以改变细胞颗粒部分中胆固醇和磷脂的含量,但未观察到细胞存活存在差异。当小鼠成纤维细胞在补充了花生四烯酸(20:4)的无血清培养基中培养24小时时,所有亚细胞膜中含有多不饱和酰基(PUFA)链的磷脂大约丰富了八倍,并且通过二苯基己三烯(DPH)的荧光偏振测量发现膜流动性增加。这些变化导致了更高的热敏感性。当使小鼠成纤维细胞产生热耐受性时,在细胞颗粒部分中未发现胆固醇和磷脂含量的变化。正常细胞和热耐受细胞的磷脂相对重量和质量以及磷脂的脂肪酸组成似乎相同。通过荧光偏振(DPH)和电子自旋共振(5-硝基硬脂酸盐)测定,在全细胞、分离的质膜以及由从细胞中提取的磷脂制备的脂质体中进行的流动性测量显示,正常成纤维细胞和热耐受成纤维细胞之间没有显著差异。得出的结论是,文献中报道的导致脂质组成差异的热适应机制与获得热耐受性的机制不同。由非致死性触发热剂量引发并在37℃诱导期后产生的热耐受细胞较低的热敏感性,并不涉及脂质组成和膜流动性的变化。然而,通过增加PUFA导致膜流动性迅速而明显(也是非致死性)的变化确实会导致热敏感性增加,这可能是因为脂质通过间接作用导致膜和/或细胞骨架中的蛋白质功能失调。