Kahsay Znabu Hadush, Medhanyie Araya Abrha, Mariam Damen Haile, Ersdal Hege Langli, Rettedal Siren
School of Public Health, College of Health Sciences, Mekelle University, Mekelle, Tigray, Ethiopia
Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Stavanger, Stavanger, Norway.
BMJ Open. 2025 Jan 21;15(1):e093377. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2024-093377.
To evaluate the feasibility of implementing family-integrated newborn care (FINC) for hospitalised preterm and low birthweight infants in Ethiopia. Despite the WHO's call for family engagement in newborn care, evidence of the feasibility of implementation remains scarce.
An observational feasibility study employing a mixed-methods design comprising a quantitative cross-sectional survey among 157 healthcare providers (HCPs) and a qualitative Participatory Rural Appraisal.
The study was conducted in 30 neonatal care units (NCUs) of hospitals in Tigray, Northern Ethiopia.
HCPs who were on duty in NCUs during the data collection period were included in the study.
Descriptive statistics were obtained for the quantitative data using STATA V.16, while qualitative data were coded and analysed using a framework analysis approach with qualitative data analysis software (Atlas.ti V.9).
In total, 157 HCPs were enrolled with a mean (SD) age of 32 (±6.8) years. Participants scored a higher weighted mean score for implementability (0.75) and a lower mean score for adaptability (0.50). Out of the 157 HCPs, the majority perceived that FINC was technically implementable (96%), conceptually acceptable (74%) and ethically correct (88%). Furthermore, 49% perceived that integrating FINC into the existing system was technically manageable, while 52% agreed that it was expandable to other healthcare facilities. However, HCPs reported lower confidence regarding its practicality (32%), integration (31%) and adaptability (16%). NCU space (97%), number of NCU rooms (87%) and increased risk of infection (83%) were perceived as potential challenges to the feasibility of FINC. More importantly, only 33% of HCPs felt that there was an organisational demand to consider FINC in NCUs. Furthermore, there was a statistically significant variation in the mean score for acceptability and perception of additional burden between age groups (p=0.04).
The current study shows that FINC is conceptually acceptable, technically implementable and expandable to other settings, with weighted mean scores of 0.75, 0.72 and 0.66, respectively. However, its practicality (0.53), integration (0.52) and adaptability (0.50) could be generally constrained mainly by the poor organisational infrastructure related to NCU space and infection prevention measures. Addressing motivational, attitudinal and competency gaps of NCU HCPs, along with organisational capacity, would be required.
评估在埃塞俄比亚对住院早产和低出生体重婴儿实施家庭综合新生儿护理(FINC)的可行性。尽管世界卫生组织呼吁家庭参与新生儿护理,但关于实施可行性的证据仍然很少。
一项采用混合方法设计的观察性可行性研究,包括对157名医疗保健提供者(HCP)进行定量横断面调查和定性参与式农村评估。
该研究在埃塞俄比亚北部提格雷地区医院的30个新生儿护理单元(NCU)中进行。
在数据收集期间在NCU值班的HCP被纳入研究。
使用STATA V.16对定量数据进行描述性统计,而定性数据则使用定性数据分析软件(Atlas.ti V.9)通过框架分析方法进行编码和分析。
总共招募了157名HCP,平均(标准差)年龄为32(±6.8)岁。参与者在可实施性方面的加权平均得分较高(0.75),在适应性方面的平均得分较低(0.50)。在157名HCP中,大多数人认为FINC在技术上是可实施的(96%)、在概念上是可接受的(74%)且在伦理上是正确的(88%)。此外,49%的人认为将FINC纳入现有系统在技术上是可管理的,而52%的人同意它可以扩展到其他医疗设施。然而,HCP对其实用性(32%)、整合性(31%)和适应性(16%)的信心较低。NCU空间(97%)、NCU房间数量(87%)和感染风险增加(83%)被视为FINC可行性的潜在挑战。更重要的是,只有33%的HCP认为在NCU中有组织需求来考虑FINC。此外,不同年龄组在可接受性平均得分和对额外负担的认知方面存在统计学显著差异(p=0.04)。
当前研究表明,FINC在概念上是可接受的,在技术上是可实施的,并且可以扩展到其他环境,加权平均得分分别为0.75、0.72和0.66。然而,其实用性(0.53)、整合性(0.52)和适应性(0.50)通常可能主要受到与NCU空间和感染预防措施相关的组织基础设施薄弱的限制。需要解决NCU HCP的动机、态度和能力差距以及组织能力问题。