Plastina Anna Franca
University of Calabria, Italy.
Patient Educ Couns. 2025 May;134:108665. doi: 10.1016/j.pec.2025.108665. Epub 2025 Jan 14.
To analyse long COVID patients' reconstruction of medical gaslighting (MG) discourse in online epistemic communities in order to identify the MG types experienced and unfold root causes.
The mixed-methods of corpus‑based critical discourse analysis was applied to an ad hoc corpus of 18 threads (n = 1176 posts) from two sub-communities on the social media site Reddit. Comparative concordance analyses were performed on the two sub-corpora to semantically code concordance lines as MG types. Critical discourse analysis was conducted to uncover power/ideological drivers of MG discourse.
Keyness log‑likelihood statistical measures displayed higher values for the pronouns I, me, you, it, they and the noun doctor(s). KWIC (Key Word in Context) output for these items exhibited seven main MG types: scapegoating, downplay, treatment refusal, psychosomatic disorder, disbelief, denial and dismissal. Concordance lines revealed three major sites of contention - epistemic knowledge, epistemic authority, long COVID indeterminacy - where MG tactics operate through epistemic injustice, ignorance, discrimination and lack of epistemic humility.
MG discourse is triggered by deep-seated ideologies rather than by mere doctor-patient interaction as a face-saving strategy which faults patients as epistemic agents.
Patients' social media mobilisation helps unmask MG tactics, raising providers' awareness of the need for perspective-taking to build collaborative doctor-patient relationships.
分析长期新冠患者在网络认知社区中对医疗煤气灯效应(MG)话语的重构,以确定所经历的MG类型并揭示其根本原因。
基于语料库的批判性话语分析的混合方法应用于来自社交媒体网站Reddit上两个子社区的18个主题帖(n = 1176个帖子)的特设语料库。对两个子语料库进行比较一致性分析,将一致性行语义编码为MG类型。进行批判性话语分析以揭示MG话语的权力/意识形态驱动因素。
关键词对数似然统计量显示代词I、me、you、it、they和名词doctor(s)的值较高。这些项目的上下文关键词(KWIC)输出显示了七种主要的MG类型:替罪羊效应、淡化、拒绝治疗、身心障碍、怀疑、否认和驳回。一致性行揭示了三个主要的争议点——认知知识、认知权威、长期新冠的不确定性——MG策略通过认知不公正、无知、歧视和缺乏认知谦逊在这些点上发挥作用。
MG话语是由根深蒂固的意识形态引发的,而不是仅仅作为一种将患者视为认知主体的保全面子的策略的医患互动。
患者在社交媒体上的动员有助于揭露MG策略,提高医疗服务提供者对采取换位思考以建立协作医患关系的必要性的认识。