Turkeš Renata, Mortier Steven, De Winne Jorg, Botteldooren Dick, Devos Paul, Latré Steven, Verdonck Tim
Internet Technology and Data Science Lab (IDLab), Department of Computer Science, University of Antwerp- Interuniversity Microelectronics Centre (imec), Antwerp, Belgium.
Wireless, Acoustics, Environment & Expert Systems (WAVES), Department of Information Technology, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
Front Neurosci. 2025 Jan 10;18:1434444. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2024.1434444. eCollection 2024.
The study of attention has been pivotal in advancing our comprehension of cognition. The goal of this study is to investigate which EEG data representations or features are most closely linked to attention, and to what extent they can handle the cross-subject variability.
We explore the features obtained from the univariate time series from a single EEG channel, such as time domain features and recurrence plots, as well as representations obtained directly from the multivariate time series, such as global field power or functional brain networks. To address the cross-subject variability in EEG data, we also investigate persistent homology features that are robust to different types of noise. The performance of the different EEG representations is evaluated with the Support Vector Machine (SVM) accuracy on the WithMe data derived from a modified digit span experiment, and is benchmarked against baseline EEG-specific models, including a deep learning architecture known for effectively learning task-specific features.
The raw EEG time series outperform each of the considered data representations, but can fall short in comparison with the black-box deep learning approach that learns the best features.
The findings are limited to the WithMe experimental paradigm, highlighting the need for further studies on diverse tasks to provide a more comprehensive understanding of their utility in the analysis of EEG data.
注意力研究在推进我们对认知的理解方面一直起着关键作用。本研究的目的是调查哪些脑电图(EEG)数据表示或特征与注意力联系最为紧密,以及它们在多大程度上能够处理个体间的变异性。
我们探索从单个EEG通道的单变量时间序列中获得的特征,如时域特征和递归图,以及直接从多变量时间序列中获得的表示,如全局场功率或功能性脑网络。为了解决EEG数据中的个体间变异性问题,我们还研究了对不同类型噪声具有鲁棒性的持久同调特征。使用支持向量机(SVM)在源自修改后的数字广度实验的WithMe数据上的准确率来评估不同EEG表示的性能,并与基线EEG特定模型进行基准比较,包括一个以有效学习任务特定特征而闻名的深度学习架构。
原始EEG时间序列的表现优于所考虑的每种数据表示,但与学习最佳特征的黑箱深度学习方法相比可能会有所不足。
研究结果仅限于WithMe实验范式,这凸显了对不同任务进行进一步研究的必要性,以便更全面地理解它们在EEG数据分析中的效用。