Gulka Emily, Rose Gwen, McCarron Michelle C, Reid Mel, Clark Megan, Madill Stéphanie J
University of Saskatchewan, School of Rehabilitation Sciences, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada.
Saskatchewan Health Authority, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada.
Ann Fam Med. 2025 Jan 27;23(1):16-23. doi: 10.1370/afm.3191.
People who are transgender or gender diverse (PTGD) often experience difficulties navigating the health care system due to a variety of factors such as lack of knowledgeable and/or culturally competent clinicians, discrimination, and structural and/or socioeconomic barriers. We sought to determine whether a peer health navigator service in the Canadian province of Saskatchewan helped connect transgender and gender-diverse clients and health care practitioners (HCPs) to resources, and how this service changed their health care experiences.
Semistructured interviews were conducted with 9 clients and 9 HCPs. Interview transcripts were then analyzed by researchers using an interpretative phenomenological approach, with qualitative data analysis software.
The most prevalent theme that emerged from interview data, from both clients and HCPs, was support for the navigators' work and a desire that the service should continue. It was reinforced by 3 subthemes: the importance that the navigators were PTGD, the ability of the navigators to connect people to services and reliable sources of information, and their skill in directly supporting clients. A fourth subtheme, primarily found among clients, was the navigators' ability to provide connections to affirming mental health care.
Clients and HCPs alike emphasized that the navigator's lived experience was invaluable and allowed them to empathize with PTGD and provide support. Furthermore, the navigators acted as a direct connection to health care services, which helped improve access for clients. Our findings underscore the need for navigator positions to become permanent within the provincial health system to improve the health care experiences of PTGD in Saskatchewan.
由于多种因素,如缺乏知识渊博和/或具备文化能力的临床医生、歧视以及结构和/或社会经济障碍,跨性别或性别多样化人群(PTGD)在医疗保健系统中就医时常常遇到困难。我们试图确定加拿大萨斯喀彻温省的一项同伴健康导航服务是否有助于将跨性别和性别多样化的客户与医疗保健从业者(HCPs)与资源联系起来,以及这项服务如何改变了他们的医疗保健体验。
对9名客户和9名医疗保健从业者进行了半结构化访谈。然后,研究人员使用定性数据分析软件,采用解释性现象学方法对访谈记录进行分析。
从客户和医疗保健从业者的访谈数据中出现的最普遍主题是对导航员工作的支持以及希望该服务能够持续下去。这一主题得到了三个子主题的强化:导航员为跨性别或性别多样化人群的重要性、导航员将人们与服务和可靠信息来源联系起来的能力,以及他们直接支持客户的技能。第四个子主题主要在客户中发现,是导航员提供与肯定性心理健康护理联系的能力。
客户和医疗保健从业者都强调,导航员的生活经历非常宝贵,使他们能够同情跨性别或性别多样化人群并提供支持。此外,导航员充当了与医疗保健服务的直接联系,有助于改善客户获得服务的机会。我们的研究结果强调,需要在省级卫生系统中设立永久性的导航员职位,以改善萨斯喀彻温省跨性别或性别多样化人群的医疗保健体验。