Kamata Maiko, Pereira-Kotze Catherine, Kerac Marko, Sibson Victoria
London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK.
First Steps Nutrition Trust, London, UK.
Matern Child Nutr. 2025 Apr;21(2):e13794. doi: 10.1111/mcn.13794. Epub 2025 Jan 31.
The International Code of Marketing of Breastmilk Substitutes ('the Code') was established to protect babies and young children from inappropriate marketing of formula milk, bottles and teats and avoid undue commercial influence on caregiver infant feeding practices, including undermining breastfeeding and safe and appropriate formula feeding. UK law encompasses some but not all of the Code. To address persisting concerns about the marketing of infant formula (IF) and follow-on formula (FoF), we assessed labelling compliance in the UK against relevant provisions in the Code, UK law and Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) Guidance Notes which interpret UK law. Data were collected during July and August 2022 by taking pictures of labels from company websites, in shops and online. We developed three labelling checklists to systematically assess compliance and to compare compliance scores between the regulatory frameworks, formula types and brands. We assessed 57 labels (n = 32 IF and n = 25 FoF) and found low overall compliance: 50% complied with UK law, 32% with Guidance Notes and 40% with the Code. None of the labels complied with provisions prohibiting idealising text and photographs, nutrition and health claims (where relevant) and cross-promotion between formula types. In conclusion, UK IF and FoF labels violate many of the provisions of all three regulatory frameworks. This is evidence of inappropriate marketing. The UK law should be better enforced and strengthened in line with the Code to protect breastfeeding, support safer, appropriate formula feeding and lessen commercial influence on infant feeding practices.
《国际母乳代用品销售守则》(以下简称“《守则》”)的制定是为了保护婴幼儿免受配方奶粉、奶瓶和奶嘴不当营销的影响,并避免商业因素对照护者的婴儿喂养行为产生不当影响,包括破坏母乳喂养以及安全、恰当的配方奶喂养。英国法律涵盖了《守则》的部分而非全部内容。为解决对婴儿配方奶粉(IF)和较大婴儿配方奶粉(FoF)营销问题的持续担忧,我们对照《守则》、英国法律以及解释英国法律的卫生和社会保健部(DHSC)指导说明中的相关规定,评估了英国产品标签的合规情况。2022年7月和8月期间,我们通过拍摄公司网站、商店及线上的产品标签照片来收集数据。我们制定了三份标签检查清单,以系统评估合规情况,并比较不同监管框架、配方奶粉类型和品牌之间的合规得分。我们评估了57个标签(n = 32个婴儿配方奶粉标签和n = 25个较大婴儿配方奶粉标签),发现总体合规率较低:50%符合英国法律,32%符合指导说明,40%符合《守则》。没有一个标签符合禁止理想化文字和图片、营养与健康声明(如适用)以及不同配方奶粉类型之间交叉促销的规定。总之,英国的婴儿配方奶粉和较大婴儿配方奶粉标签违反了所有三个监管框架的许多规定。这是不当营销的证据。英国法律应更好地执行并按照《守则》予以加强,以保护母乳喂养、支持更安全、恰当的配方奶喂养,并减少商业因素对婴儿喂养行为的影响。