Andersen B L, Tewfik H H
J Pers Soc Psychol. 1985 Apr;48(4):1024-32. doi: 10.1037//0022-3514.48.4.1024.
A common form of cancer treatment is radiation therapy. In this investigation individual differences in the psychological reactions of 45 patients undergoing external treatment were examined in the context of the Janis (1958) and linear decline models (e.g., Spielberger, Auerbach, Wadworth, Dunn, & Taulbee, 1973) of medical stressor anxiety. Evaluation included pre- and postradiation assessments of the subjects' state and trait anxiety, somatic complaints, and treatment side effects. Technologists administering the daily treatments assessed behavioral indicants of affective distress. Data analyses revealed that increases in complaints and side effects were reported by all patients at treatment conclusion. More interesting, significant changes in state anxiety were obtained from pre- to posttreatment: (a) Patients with an initial high level of anxiety reported a significant reduction, although they remained the most anxious subgroup; (b) patients with a moderate level of pretreatment anxiety reported no change; and (c) patients with low levels of anxiety reported significant increases in state anxiety. No change in trait anxiety was found for any group, suggesting that the foregoing changes in state anxiety were not simply attributable to regression. Data trends suggested that patients who were either low or high in state anxiety were also characterized by more anger or hostility than patients moderate in anxiety. The findings are consistent with the Janis model, which posits that in threatening situations the level of fear can potentially determine the adequacy of adaptation.
癌症治疗的一种常见形式是放射疗法。在这项调查中,以贾尼斯(1958年)和医学应激源焦虑的线性下降模型(例如,斯皮尔伯格、奥尔巴赫、沃兹沃思、邓恩和陶尔比,1973年)为背景,研究了45名接受外部治疗的患者心理反应的个体差异。评估包括放疗前后对受试者的状态焦虑、特质焦虑、躯体不适和治疗副作用的评估。进行日常治疗的技术人员评估了情感困扰的行为指标。数据分析显示,所有患者在治疗结束时报告的不适和副作用都有所增加。更有趣的是,从治疗前到治疗后,状态焦虑有显著变化:(a)初始焦虑水平高的患者报告焦虑显著降低,尽管他们仍然是最焦虑的亚组;(b)治疗前焦虑水平中等的患者报告没有变化;(c)焦虑水平低的患者报告状态焦虑显著增加。没有发现任何一组的特质焦虑有变化,这表明上述状态焦虑的变化并非仅仅归因于回归。数据趋势表明,状态焦虑水平低或高的患者也比焦虑水平中等的患者表现出更多的愤怒或敌意。这些发现与贾尼斯模型一致,该模型假定在威胁性情境中,恐惧水平可能决定适应的充分性。