El Sissy Franck Neil, Bisdorff Annouk, Perrier Alexandre, Guillerm Erell, Denis Jérôme, Favre Löetitia, Aubertin Mathilde, Eyries Mélanie, Coulet Florence
Department of Pathology, Lariboisière Hospital, Assistance Publique Hôpitaux de Paris, 2 rue Ambroise Paré, 75010, Paris, France.
University of Paris Cité, Faculty of Medicine, Paris, France.
Mol Diagn Ther. 2025 May;29(3):367-380. doi: 10.1007/s40291-025-00770-0. Epub 2025 Feb 3.
Superficial vascular anomalies are complex disorders characterized by abnormal vascular growth. Next-generation sequencing has recently identified somatic genetic alterations associated with these malformations, offering new insights for targeted treatments. However, tissue biopsies for genetic testing can be invasive and difficult to obtain, especially in arteriovenous malformations (AVM) with hemorrhagic risks. A liquid biopsy, a non-invasive approach, offers a promising solution by detecting genetic mutations in cell-free DNA. This pilot study aimed to evaluate the feasibility of using a liquid biopsy for the genetic analysis of patients with superficial vascular anomalies through cell-free DNA sampling. Additionally, it explored whether specific sampling sites, such as the afferent artery, nidus, and efferent vein, could enhance the sensitivity of detecting pathogenic variants in patients with AVM.
A total of 88 patients were enrolled, including 55 with AVM and 33 with lymphatic malformations. For patients with AVM, cell-free DNA samples were collected from peripheral blood, efferent veins, afferent arteries, and the AVM nidus. In patients with lymphatic malformations, cystic lymphatic fluid was collected by a direct puncture during diagnostic procedures. A molecular analysis was performed using a targeted gene panel relevant to somatic alterations in solid tumors. Pathogenic variants were validated by digital polymerase chain reaction for patients with lymphatic malformations.
Pathogenic variants were identified in 23.6% of patients with AVM, predominantly in MAP2K1 and KRAS genes, with higher sensitivity near the AVM nidus. In addition, pathogenic variants were identified in 27.3% of patients with lymphatic malformations, all involving the PIK3CA gene. Despite the lower sensitivity of a cell-free DNA analysis compared with a tissue biopsy, especially in patients with AVM, the detection rate suggests the utility for a cell-free DNA analysis, particularly when a tissue biopsy is not feasible.
This study confirms the feasibility of using a cell-free DNA liquid biopsy for genotyping patients with superficial vascular anomalies, although a tissue biopsy remains the gold standard for comprehensive genetic profiling because of its higher sensitivity. A liquid biopsy offers a non-invasive option for molecular analysis that is useful as a preliminary or alternative approach when direct tissue sampling is not possible. Importantly, the sensitivity of cell-free DNA sampling in AVM appeared highest when obtained close to the nidus, indicating an optimal sampling location for future studies. Further research is needed to improve detection sensitivity, especially for samples taken near the nidus, to validate and strengthen these findings. Although our study focused on superficial/extra-cranial AVM, further research should assess the applicability of this approach to cerebral AVM, where a tissue biopsy is particularly risky.
浅表血管异常是一类以血管生长异常为特征的复杂疾病。新一代测序技术最近发现了与这些畸形相关的体细胞基因改变,为靶向治疗提供了新的见解。然而,用于基因检测的组织活检具有侵入性且难以获取,尤其是在有出血风险的动静脉畸形(AVM)中。液体活检作为一种非侵入性方法,通过检测游离DNA中的基因突变提供了一个有前景的解决方案。这项初步研究旨在评估通过游离DNA采样对浅表血管异常患者进行基因分析的液体活检的可行性。此外,它还探讨了特定采样部位,如输入动脉、病灶和输出静脉,是否能提高AVM患者致病变异的检测灵敏度。
共纳入88例患者,其中55例为AVM患者,33例为淋巴管畸形患者。对于AVM患者,从外周血、输出静脉、输入动脉和AVM病灶采集游离DNA样本。对于淋巴管畸形患者,在诊断过程中通过直接穿刺收集囊性淋巴液。使用与实体瘤体细胞改变相关的靶向基因panel进行分子分析。通过数字聚合酶链反应对淋巴管畸形患者的致病变异进行验证。
在23.6%的AVM患者中鉴定出致病变异,主要存在于MAP2K1和KRAS基因中,在AVM病灶附近的检测灵敏度更高。此外,在27.3%的淋巴管畸形患者中鉴定出致病变异,均涉及PIK3CA基因。尽管游离DNA分析的灵敏度低于组织活检,尤其是在AVM患者中,但检测率表明游离DNA分析具有实用性,特别是在组织活检不可行时。
本研究证实了使用游离DNA液体活检对浅表血管异常患者进行基因分型的可行性,尽管由于组织活检灵敏度更高,它仍然是全面基因分析的金标准。液体活检为分子分析提供了一种非侵入性选择,在无法进行直接组织采样时,可作为初步或替代方法。重要的是,在AVM中,靠近病灶获取的游离DNA采样灵敏度似乎最高,这表明这是未来研究的最佳采样位置。需要进一步研究以提高检测灵敏度,特别是对于在病灶附近采集的样本,以验证和强化这些发现。虽然我们的研究聚焦于浅表/颅外AVM,但进一步研究应评估该方法对脑AVM的适用性,在脑AVM中组织活检风险尤其高。