Hardie Jessica Halliday, Arseniev-Koehler Alina, Seltzer Judith A, Foster Jacob G
Hunter College and the Graduate Center, City University of New York, United States.
assistant professor of sociology, Purdue University, and postdoctoral fellow of biomedical informatics, University of California, San Diego, United States.
RSF. 2024 Sep;10(5):165-187. doi: 10.7758/rsf.2024.10.5.07.
We develop a novel application of machine learning and apply it to the interview transcripts from the American Voices Project (N = 1,396), using discourse atom topic modeling to explore social class variation in the centrality of family in adults' lives. We take a two-phase approach, first analyzing transcripts at the person level and then at the line level. Our findings suggest that family, as represented by talk, is more central in the lives of those without a college degree than among the college educated. However, the degree of institutional overlap between family and other key institutions-health, work, religion, and criminal justice-does not vary by education. We interpret these findings in the context of debates about the deinstitutionalization of family in the contemporary United States. This demonstrates the value of a new method for analyzing qualitative interview data at scale. We address ways to expand the use of this method to shed light on educational disparities.
我们开发了一种新颖的机器学习应用,并将其应用于美国之声项目(N = 1396)的访谈记录,使用话语原子主题建模来探索家庭在成年人生活中的核心地位的社会阶层差异。我们采用两阶段方法,首先在个人层面分析记录,然后在线条层面进行分析。我们的研究结果表明,以谈话所代表的家庭,在没有大学学位的人的生活中比在受过大学教育的人当中更为核心。然而,家庭与其他关键机构——健康、工作、宗教和刑事司法——之间的制度重叠程度并不会因教育程度而有所不同。我们在当代美国关于家庭去制度化的辩论背景下解读这些发现。这证明了一种大规模分析定性访谈数据的新方法的价值。我们探讨了扩展此方法的使用以阐明教育差距的方法。