Kitsaras George, Boothman Nicola, Gomez Juliana, Goodwin Michaela, Muzammil Momina, Walsh Tanya
Division of Dentistry, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Colgate-Palmolive Company, Dental Health Unit, Williams House, Manchester Science Park, Manchester, M15 6SE, UK.
BMC Oral Health. 2025 Feb 11;25(1):223. doi: 10.1186/s12903-025-05573-7.
The main aim of this cluster randomised controlled trial is to explore the feasibility of a school-based brushing program utilising a smart, connected brush in children.
Students aged 8 to 11 years in 6 primary schools across Manchester, UK were approached for this study. All children received a smart, connected toothbrush which captured information on coverage, duration and frequency of brushing. Teachers had access to class-level digital dashboards summarising brushing habits to set challenges for the students. Additionally, children in schools randomised to the toothbrush plus text messaging trial arm received text message support (delivered to their parents' mobile phones). Outcomes included: (a) consent rate, (b) recruitment rate recorded as the number of participants who completed at least one of the study surveys post-consents, and (c) acceptability of the interventions on schools and parents through a mixed methods approach.
Average age of parents was 39.8 years (SD5.94) while the average age of children was 9.7 years (SD1.56). Most parents and children came from households in the most deprived decile based on their Index of Multiple Deprivation (IMD) scores with 77 households (52.4%) scoring 1 (most deprived). Out of 753 eligible participants across all 6 schools, 409 were consented (54.3% consent rate) with 148 participants completing baseline measurements (36.8%). During the study, there was only 1 drop out. In terms of acceptability, parents found the study very enjoyable (average score of 8.9/10), and found the brush and app easy to use (average score of 8.7/10). Those parents who additionally received the text messages found them easy to understand and useful (average score of 8.9/10). In total, 91.6% of parents would recommend the brush and the intervention to family and friends. Three key facilitators ((a) enhancing children's self-reliance, (b) increased engagement through the use of visual cues and (c) increased motivation (due to gamification) potentially supported children's engagement with the brush and app.
Low dropout rates and very positive feedback highlight the potential of this intervention. Future studies should consider how to quantify changes in children's oral health, address loss of questionnaire completion and harness the opportunities this study provided.
The study was registered at ISRCTN registration number ISRCTN77803149 on the 28th December 2023.
这项整群随机对照试验的主要目的是探索在儿童中使用智能连接牙刷开展校内刷牙计划的可行性。
研究面向英国曼彻斯特6所小学中8至11岁的学生。所有儿童均获得一支智能连接牙刷,该牙刷可获取刷牙覆盖范围、时长和频率等信息。教师可通过班级层面的数字仪表盘汇总刷牙习惯,为学生设定挑战。此外,随机分配到牙刷加短信试验组的学校中的儿童会收到短信支持(发送至其家长手机)。结果包括:(a)同意率;(b)招募率,记录为同意后完成至少一项研究调查的参与者数量;(c)通过混合方法评估干预措施对学校和家长的可接受性。
家长的平均年龄为39.8岁(标准差5.94),儿童的平均年龄为9.7岁(标准差1.56)。根据多重贫困指数(IMD)得分,大多数家长和儿童来自最贫困十分位的家庭,77户家庭(52.4%)得分为1(最贫困)。在所有6所学校的753名符合条件的参与者中,409人同意参与(同意率54.3%),148名参与者完成了基线测量(36.8%)。在研究期间,仅有1人退出。在可接受性方面,家长认为该研究非常有趣(平均得分8.9/10),并认为牙刷和应用程序易于使用(平均得分8.7/10)。那些额外收到短信的家长认为短信易于理解且有用(平均得分8.9/10)。总体而言,91.6%的家长愿意向家人和朋友推荐该牙刷及干预措施。三个关键促进因素((a)增强儿童的自理能力,(b)通过使用视觉提示增加参与度,(c)(由于游戏化)提高积极性)可能有助于儿童使用牙刷和应用程序。
低退出率和非常积极的反馈凸显了这项干预措施的潜力。未来研究应考虑如何量化儿童口腔健康的变化,解决问卷完成率低的问题,并利用本研究提供的机会。
该研究于2023年12月28日在ISRCTN注册,注册号为ISRCTN77803149。