Santamaría-Vázquez Eduardo, Estudillo-Guerra Anayali, Ali Lna, Martinez Diana, Hornero Roberto, Morales-Quezada Leon
Biomedical Engineering Group, University of Valladolid, Valladolid, Spain.
Centro de Investigación Biomédica en Red en Bioingeniería, Biomateriales y Nanomedicina, Madrid, Spain.
Front Hum Neurosci. 2025 Feb 7;19:1478501. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2025.1478501. eCollection 2025.
Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a neurodevelopmental condition that affects cognitive, academic, behavioral, emotional, and social functioning, primarily in children. Despite its high prevalence, current pharmacological treatments are not effective in 30% of cases and show poor long-term adherence. Non-pharmacological interventions can complement medication-based treatments to improve results. Among these therapies, neurofeedback (NFB) and respiratory biofeedback (R-BFB) have shown promise in treating ADHD symptoms. Moreover, median nerve stimulation (MNS) can help to enhance the efficacy of these treatments, but it has never been explored in this context. This study aimed to: (1) investigate the effectiveness of a combined R-BFB and NFB intervention to treat ADHD, and (2) explore the potential benefits of MNS in enhancing the proposed intervention.
Sixty children with ADHD participated in the study, divided into two experimental groups. The active group received MNS, and the sham group received sham MNS. Both groups performed the NFB/R-BFB treatment. Clinical assessments (i.e., Conner's parent rating scale) and electroencephalography (EEG) measurements were taken before the intervention, immediately after treatment, and one month later.
The results showed that the combined therapy significantly improved behavioral problems, anxiety, hyperactivity, and impulsivity-hyperactivity. Moreover, MNS enhanced the positive effects of the intervention, as the active group achieved higher improvement compared to the sham group. EEG analysis revealed significant changes in spontaneous brain activity, with an increase in frontal theta power ( = 0.0125) associated with reduced anxiety, which might explain the clinical outcomes. These changes were maintained 1 month after the intervention ( = 0.0325). Correlations between EEG changes and clinical outcomes were observed, suggesting a potential relationship between neurophysiological markers and ADHD symptoms measured by standardized scales.
The study findings suggest that the proposed R-BFB/NFB intervention may be an effective non-pharmacological therapy for ADHD, with the additional application of MNS potentially enhancing its effects.
注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)是一种神经发育疾病,主要影响儿童的认知、学业、行为、情绪和社交功能。尽管其患病率很高,但目前的药物治疗在30%的病例中无效,且长期依从性较差。非药物干预可以补充基于药物的治疗以改善治疗效果。在这些疗法中,神经反馈(NFB)和呼吸生物反馈(R-BFB)在治疗ADHD症状方面已显示出前景。此外,正中神经刺激(MNS)有助于提高这些治疗的疗效,但此前从未在此背景下进行过探索。本研究旨在:(1)调查R-BFB和NFB联合干预治疗ADHD的有效性,以及(2)探索MNS在增强所提出干预措施方面的潜在益处。
60名患有ADHD的儿童参与了该研究,分为两个实验组。活性组接受MNS,假手术组接受假MNS。两组均进行NFB/R-BFB治疗。在干预前、治疗后立即以及1个月后进行临床评估(即康纳父母评定量表)和脑电图(EEG)测量。
结果表明,联合治疗显著改善了行为问题、焦虑、多动和冲动多动。此外,MNS增强了干预的积极效果,因为活性组比假手术组取得了更高的改善。EEG分析显示自发脑活动有显著变化,额叶θ波功率增加(P = 0.0125)与焦虑减轻相关,这可能解释了临床结果。这些变化在干预后1个月仍持续存在(P = 0.0325)。观察到EEG变化与临床结果之间存在相关性,表明神经生理标志物与通过标准化量表测量的ADHD症状之间存在潜在关系。
研究结果表明,所提出的R-BFB/NFB干预可能是一种有效的ADHD非药物治疗方法,额外应用MNS可能会增强其效果。