O'Hara M J, Lahiri A, Whittington J R, Crawley J C, Raftery E B
Br Heart J. 1985 Jun;53(6):616-23. doi: 10.1136/hrt.53.6.616.
One hundred and three patients who underwent coronary arteriography were studied by thallium imaging and the results analysed by Bayesian principles to assess the usefulness of semiquantitative stress thallium imaging for predicting the presence or absence of multivessel coronary disease. Significant disease was found in 80 patients, of whom 77 had abnormal thallium scans (sensitivity 96%). Thallium images were normal in 15 of 23 patients with no significant disease (specificity 65%). Multiple thallium segmental defects were found to be 90% sensitive and 65% specific for multivessel coronary artery disease and were present in 80% of patients with left main stem disease and in 93% of patients with triple vessel disease. A single thallium defect or normal scan excluded multivessel, left main, and triple vessel disease with 81%, 94%, and 91% predictive accuracy respectively. By Bayesian analysis the predictive accuracy for excluding multivessel disease was greater than 90% in patients with a pretest probability of multivessel disease of less than or equal to 40%. Coronary arteriography to exclude multivessel disease is therefore unnecessary in a high proportion of patients with known or suspected coronary artery disease.
对103例行冠状动脉造影的患者进行了铊显像研究,并根据贝叶斯原理对结果进行分析,以评估半定量负荷铊显像对预测多支冠状动脉疾病有无的有效性。80例患者发现有明显病变,其中77例铊扫描异常(敏感性96%)。23例无明显病变的患者中有15例铊显像正常(特异性65%)。发现多个铊节段缺损对多支冠状动脉疾病的敏感性为90%,特异性为65%,在左主干病变患者中80%存在,在三支血管病变患者中93%存在。单个铊缺损或正常扫描分别以81%、94%和91%的预测准确率排除多支血管、左主干和三支血管病变。通过贝叶斯分析,在多支血管疾病预测试概率小于或等于40%的患者中,排除多支血管疾病的预测准确率大于90%。因此,在已知或疑似冠状动脉疾病的患者中,很大一部分患者无需进行冠状动脉造影以排除多支血管疾病。