Williams G D, Aitken S S, Malin H
J Stud Alcohol. 1985 May;46(3):223-7. doi: 10.15288/jsa.1985.46.223.
Reliability estimates for the measures of alcohol consumption used in a household survey were examined. Respondents who had not consumed any alcohol within the previous year and those under age 18 were excluded from the survey, yielding a sample of 1395 (48% men). With one survey that involved a 2-week recall period and another that involved a 4-week period, three methods for estimating reliability were employed: alternate forms, test-retest and a combined method. Validity was also examined using a 30-day drinking diary as a criterion. The findings indicate high levels of reliability, averaging .91 for the consumption measures of beer, wine and distilled spirits. Validity estimates were also fairly substantial but not uniformly so across the different beverage types. In general, the results suggest that these consumption measures can be used with considerable confidence.
对一项家庭调查中使用的酒精消费测量方法的可靠性估计进行了检验。过去一年未饮酒的受访者以及18岁以下的受访者被排除在调查之外,最终得到一个1395人的样本(48%为男性)。一项调查采用了为期2周的回忆期,另一项采用了为期4周的回忆期,使用了三种估计可靠性的方法:替代形式法、重测法和一种组合方法。还以一份30天饮酒日记为标准对效度进行了检验。研究结果表明可靠性水平很高,啤酒、葡萄酒和蒸馏酒消费测量的平均可靠性为0.91。效度估计也相当可观,但在不同饮料类型中并不一致。总体而言,结果表明这些消费测量方法可以相当可靠地使用。