Sinha Nibha, Patle Sonali
Department of Humanities and Social Sciences, Jaypee Institute of Information Technology, Noida, Uttar Pradesh, India.
Online Learning Department, Superprof.com, San Francisco, United States.
Indian J Community Med. 2025 Jan-Feb;50(1):169-174. doi: 10.4103/ijcm.ijcm_813_23. Epub 2025 Jan 23.
When the coronavirus vaccine was launched, many Hindi language videos on YouTube were uploaded and audiences were accessing these videos in good numbers. However, the scientific evaluation of these videos was never done. There is a need to understand the accuracy, validity, and quality of these videos so that they can further be utilized for other health awareness purposes. The study objective was to evaluate the validity, quality, and accuracy of the Hindi videos that were viewed the most on YouTube.
Two search terms, "COVID-19 Vaccine-Hindi" and "Corona vaccine Hindi," were used, and the most viewed 50 videos were selected. All the videos were manually coded and statistically evaluated. Two public health researchers evaluated all the videos blinded to each other using the DISCERN, GQS, and JAMA scales. The correlation score was calculated to know the agreement between them. Scores of professionals and news-based organizations were also compared.
Out of all 50 videos, professionals uploaded 48% of videos, and news-based organizations uploaded 46% of videos. The DISCERN median was found to be 9.00 (5-10), the JAMA median score was 6.00 (3-8), and the DISCERN score was 40.50 (16-49). DISCERN, JAMA, and GQS scores were also calculated separately for both observers, and no statistically significant difference was found. Between both the observer's agreement was found with statistical significance.
YouTube was found to be an excellent source of information on the coronavirus vaccine in the Hindi language. Almost all 50 videos had wide viewership, so health professionals and news media organizations cannot ignore this popular platform to improve the health awareness of citizens in a developing country like India.
冠状病毒疫苗推出后,YouTube上上传了许多印地语视频,大量观众观看了这些视频。然而,从未对这些视频进行过科学评估。有必要了解这些视频的准确性、有效性和质量,以便它们能进一步用于其他健康宣传目的。本研究的目的是评估YouTube上观看次数最多的印地语视频的有效性、质量和准确性。
使用两个搜索词“COVID-19疫苗 - 印地语”和“冠状病毒疫苗印地语”,选取观看次数最多的50个视频。所有视频均进行人工编码和统计评估。两名公共卫生研究人员使用DISCERN、GQS和JAMA量表对所有视频进行相互盲评。计算相关分数以了解他们之间的一致性。还比较了专业人士和新闻类组织的分数。
在所有50个视频中,专业人士上传了48%的视频,新闻类组织上传了46%的视频。发现DISCERN中位数为9.00(5 - 10),JAMA中位数分数为6.00(3 - 8),GQS分数为40.50(16 - 49)。还分别为两位观察者计算了DISCERN、JAMA和GQS分数,未发现统计学上的显著差异。两位观察者之间的一致性具有统计学意义。
发现YouTube是印地语冠状病毒疫苗信息的绝佳来源。几乎所有50个视频都有广泛的观众群体,因此在印度这样的发展中国家,卫生专业人员和新闻媒体组织不能忽视这个受欢迎的平台,以提高公民的健康意识。