Galindo-Aldana Gilberto, Montoya-Rivera Luis Arturo, Esqueda-Elizondo Jose Jaime, Inzunza-Gonzalez Everardo, Garcia-Guerrero Enrique Efren, Padilla-Lopez Alfredo, Bautista Tara G, Torres-González Cynthia
Laboratory of Neuroscience and Cognition, Facultad de Ciencias Administrativas, Sociales e Ingeniería, Universidad Autonoma de Baja California, Carr. Est. No. 3 s/n Col. Gutierrez, Mexicali 21700, BC, Mexico.
Facultad de Ciencias Químicas e Ingeniería, Universidad Autonoma de Baja California, Calzada Universidad No. 14418, Tijuana 22424, BC, Mexico.
Brain Sci. 2025 Mar 20;15(3):324. doi: 10.3390/brainsci15030324.
Mindfulness-based interventions (MBIs) have emerged as an alternative intervention for symptoms of psychological and psychiatric conditions, such as depression, anxiety, and emotional discomfort. Over the last ten years, MBIs have established a growing body of evidence that shows cognitive and neurophysiological benefits. Depression and anxiety are conditions with a high prevalence in the world population. In developing countries, it is reported that, given the conditions of being at a social disadvantage, anxiety and depression are higher, resulting in compromised psychological well-being and mental health. This systematic review aims to quantitatively and qualitatively assess changes in the neuropsychological, particularly executive functioning and social cognition domains, and electroencephalographical (EEG) effects of MBIs. A systematic review was conducted using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) in three databases, Web of Science, Scopus, and EBSCO MedLine complete; 14,464 articles were found, 141 articles evaluated the effects of MBI on executive functioning, and 16 included both as in qualitative and quantitative variables. The qualitative results show that the research on the effects of MBI on behavior and cognitive skills, including executive function, social cognition, and EEG analysis, is very scarce but consistent in suggesting strong correlations on cognitive and electrophysiological alpha-beta proportions asymmetry on frontal areas. Undoubtedly, executive functions, as a behavioral regulatory and self-monitoring system, are the most popular study of interest in the literature, including emotional regulation, awareness, planning, social skills, and focused attention. Although there are fewer studies assessing the effects of MBIs on social cognition skills. The funnel plot showed a symmetrical distribution but ranked out of significant correlation. Most estimates of treatment effects are positive (58%); however, the average outcome observed did not significantly differ from zero. This study concludes that the research integrating the analysis of the electrophysiological and executive function effects of MBI shows important methodological variations and clinical conditions, which explains the significant results reported individually. Even when most of the literature reports positive effects of MBIs on several behavioral and neurophysiological domains, there are still confounding factors that must be taken into consideration by researchers and clinicians before attributing possible inaccurate or generalizable benefits.
基于正念的干预措施(MBIs)已成为一种针对心理和精神疾病症状的替代干预方法,如抑郁症、焦虑症和情绪不适。在过去十年中,MBIs已积累了越来越多的证据,表明其具有认知和神经生理学益处。抑郁症和焦虑症在世界人口中普遍存在。据报道,在发展中国家,由于处于社会劣势地位,焦虑症和抑郁症更为高发,导致心理健康和精神健康受损。本系统评价旨在定量和定性评估MBIs对神经心理学的影响,特别是执行功能和社会认知领域,以及脑电图(EEG)效应。使用系统评价和Meta分析的首选报告项目(PRISMA)在三个数据库(科学网、Scopus和EBSCO MedLine完整版)中进行了系统评价;共找到14464篇文章,141篇文章评估了MBI对执行功能的影响,16篇文章将其作为定性和定量变量纳入。定性结果表明,关于MBI对行为和认知技能(包括执行功能、社会认知和EEG分析)影响的研究非常稀少,但一致表明额叶区域的认知和电生理α-β比例不对称存在强相关性。毫无疑问,执行功能作为一种行为调节和自我监测系统,是文献中最受关注的研究领域,包括情绪调节、意识、计划、社交技能和注意力集中。虽然评估MBIs对社会认知技能影响的研究较少。漏斗图显示分布对称,但未达到显著相关性。大多数治疗效果估计为阳性(58%);然而,观察到的平均结果与零无显著差异。本研究得出结论,整合MBI电生理和执行功能影响分析的研究显示出重要的方法学差异和临床条件,这解释了个别报告的显著结果。即使大多数文献报道MBIs对多个行为和神经生理领域有积极影响,但在归因可能不准确或可推广的益处之前,研究人员和临床医生仍必须考虑到混杂因素。