Butler Christopher C, Mash Robert, Gobat Nina, Little Paul, Makasa Mpundu, Makwero Martha, Mills Edward J, Sit Regina Wing-Shan, Bachmann Max O
Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Division of Family Medicine and Primary Care, Stellenbosch University, Stellenbosch, South Africa.
Lancet Glob Health. 2025 Apr;13(4):e749-e758. doi: 10.1016/S2214-109X(24)00513-8.
The World Health Assembly has called for clinical trials to be strengthened, with broader demographic and geographical inclusion of populations. The objective of this paper is to highlight the importance of rigorous evidence to maximise the health gains of primary health care, and to identify strategies for strengthening clinical trials in primary care. Clinical trials should evaluate interventions of all kinds, including preventive manoeuvres, diagnostics, health service research questions, behavioural and educational interventions, vaccines, therapeutics, and policies. Single question trials can be inefficient and seldom strengthen health systems. New approaches that develop or strengthen health research infrastructure and embed research in primary care will identify effective interventions faster, how to deliver them better, and more accurately determine to whom they should be applied. When patients and community members, together with researchers, contribute to conception, design, and delivery, research will result in more useful, relevant evidence. Traditional site-based recruitment (where the participant comes to the trial) can be complemented by approaches that give people the opportunity to contribute regardless of where they live and receive their health care (taking the trials to the people). However, this cannot be done until regulation is modernised to make it easier for health-care professionals, researchers, and research participants to co-design, deliver, and implement such trials, and to develop processes to coordinate and monitor progress against goals for budget shifts, delivery, engagement, trials activity, and impact. Strengthening primary care trials is especially important in those regions where primary care is most under-resourced and is key to pandemic preparedness. Not doing so risks widening inequities further.
世界卫生大会呼吁加强临床试验,纳入更广泛的人口统计学和地理区域的人群。本文的目的是强调严格证据对于最大化初级卫生保健健康收益的重要性,并确定加强初级保健临床试验的策略。临床试验应评估各种干预措施,包括预防措施、诊断方法、卫生服务研究问题、行为和教育干预措施、疫苗、治疗方法及政策。单一问题的试验可能效率低下,且很少能加强卫生系统。开发或加强卫生研究基础设施并将研究嵌入初级保健的新方法,将更快地识别有效的干预措施、更好地确定如何实施这些措施,并更准确地确定应将其应用于哪些人群。当患者和社区成员与研究人员共同参与构思、设计和实施时,研究将产生更有用、更相关的证据。传统的基于地点的招募方式(即参与者到试验地点)可以辅以其他方式,让人们无论居住何处及接受医疗服务的地点,都有机会参与(将试验带给人们)。然而,在监管实现现代化之前,这是无法做到的,现代化监管应使医疗保健专业人员、研究人员和研究参与者更容易共同设计、实施和开展此类试验,并制定流程来协调和监测在预算转移、实施、参与、试验活动及影响等目标方面的进展。在那些初级保健资源最为匮乏的地区,加强初级保健试验尤为重要,这也是大流行防范的关键。不这样做可能会进一步加剧不平等。