Morena Nina, Htite Elly Dimya, Ahisar Yitzchok, Hayman Victoria, Rentschler Carrie A, Meguerditchian Ari N
Department of Art History and Communication Studies, McGill University, McCall McBain Arts Building, Room 155, 853 Sherbrooke Street West, Montreal, QC, H3A 0G5, Canada, 1 514-398-2850.
Faculty of Medicine, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada.
JMIR Infodemiology. 2025 Mar 31;5:e66812. doi: 10.2196/66812.
Many women with breast cancer document their experiences in YouTube vlogs, which may serve as peer-to-peer and community support.
This study aimed to determine (1) the forms of content about breast cancer that tend to be discussed in vlogs, (2) the reasons why women choose to vlog their breast cancer experiences, and (3) the potential for breast cancer vlogs to serve as an alternative or complement to peer-to-peer support as well as a site of digital community overall.
YouTube was searched in incognito mode in November 2023 using the search terms "breast cancer vlog." A maximum of 10 videos/creator were included based on viewership and date created. Video characteristics collected included title; length; number of views, likes, comments; and playlist inclusion. Videos were assessed for sponsorship; presence of explanation and discussion on breast cancer; type of content; and themes. Creator characteristics included age, location, and engagement approaches. Descriptive and content analyses were performed to analyze video content and potential areas where peer-to-peer support may be provided.
Ninety vlogs by 13 creators were included, all from personal accounts. The mean (SD) video length, number of views, and number of comments were 21.4 (9.1) minutes, 266,780 (534,465), and 1485 (3422), respectively. Of the 90 videos, 35 (39%) included hashtags, and 11 (12%) included paid sponsorships. The most common filming location was the home (87/90; 97%), followed by the hospital (28/90; 31%) and car (19/90; 21%). Home vlogs were most often set in the living room (43/90; 44%), bedroom (32/90; 33%), or kitchen (20/90; 21%). Thirty-four of 60 videos (57%) included treatment visuals and physical findings. Creators addressed motivation for vlogging in 44/90 videos (49%); the two most common reasons were wanting to build a community and helping others. In 42/90 videos (47%), creators explicitly expressed emotion. Most common themes were treatment (77/90; 86%), mental health (73/90; 81%), adverse effects (65/90; 72%), appearance (57/90; 63%), and family relationships (33/90; 37%). Patient-directed advice was offered in 52/90 videos (58%), mostly on treatment-related issues. In 51/90 videos (57%), creators provided explicit treatment definitions. Chemotherapy was discussed in 63/90 videos (70%); surgery in 52/90 (58%), primarily mastectomy; radiation in 27/90 (30%); and general adverse effects in 64/90 (71%). Twenty-two of 90 videos (24%) were about a new diagnosis. When mentioned (40/90; 44%), the most common creator location was the United States. When mentioned (27/90; 30%), the most common age was 20-29 years.
The dedication to building community support by vlog creators, and the personal nature of their storytelling, may make vlogs a potential resource for peer-to-peer support.
许多乳腺癌患者会在YouTube视频博客中记录自己的经历,这可以作为一种 peer-to-peer(对等)和社区支持。
本研究旨在确定(1)视频博客中倾向于讨论的乳腺癌相关内容形式,(2)女性选择通过视频博客记录其乳腺癌经历的原因,以及(3)乳腺癌视频博客作为 peer-to-peer 支持的替代或补充以及整体数字社区场所的潜力。
2023年11月,使用搜索词“乳腺癌视频博客”在隐身模式下搜索YouTube。根据观看量和创建日期,最多纳入10个视频/创作者。收集的视频特征包括标题、时长、观看次数、点赞数、评论数以及播放列表收录情况。评估视频是否有赞助、是否存在对乳腺癌的解释和讨论、内容类型以及主题。创作者特征包括年龄、地点和互动方式。进行描述性和内容分析以分析视频内容以及可能提供 peer-to-peer 支持的潜在领域。
纳入了13位创作者的90个视频博客,均来自个人账户。视频的平均(标准差)时长、观看次数和评论数分别为21.4(9.1)分钟、266,780(534,465)和1485(3422)。在90个视频中,35个(39%)包含主题标签,11个(12%)包含付费赞助。最常见的拍摄地点是家中(87/90;97%),其次是医院(28/90;31%)和汽车(19/90;21%)。家庭视频博客大多拍摄于客厅(43/90;44%)、卧室(32/90;33%)或厨房(20/90;21%)。60个视频中有34个(57%)包含治疗视觉画面和身体检查结果。44个(49%)视频中的创作者提到了制作视频博客的动机;最常见的两个原因是想要建立社区和帮助他人。42个(47%)视频中的创作者明确表达了情感。最常见的主题是治疗(77/90;86%)、心理健康(73/90;81%)、不良反应(65/90;72%)、外貌(57/90;63%)和家庭关系(33/90;37%)。52个(58%)视频提供了针对患者的建议,大多是关于治疗相关问题。51个(57%)视频中的创作者提供了明确的治疗定义。63个(70%)视频讨论了化疗;52个(58%)讨论了手术,主要是乳房切除术;27个(30%)讨论了放疗;64个(71%)讨论了一般不良反应。90个视频中有22个(24%)是关于新诊断的。当被提及(40/90;44%)时,最常见的创作者所在地是美国。当被提及(27/90;30%)时,最常见的年龄是20 - 29岁。
视频博客创作者致力于建立社区支持,且其讲述具有个人性质,这可能使视频博客成为 peer-to-peer 支持的潜在资源。