Kelly-Hedrick Margot, Grunberg Paul H, Brochu Felicia, Zelkowitz Phyllis
Department of Psychiatry, Jewish General Hospital, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Department of Psychology, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada.
J Med Internet Res. 2018 May 23;20(5):e10199. doi: 10.2196/10199.
Infertility patients frequently use the internet to find fertility-related information and support from people in similar circumstances. YouTube is increasingly used as a source of health-related information and may influence health decision making. There have been no studies examining the content of infertility-related videos on YouTube.
The purpose of this study was to (1) describe the content of highly viewed videos on YouTube related to infertility and (2) identify video characteristics that relate to viewer preference.
Using the search term "infertility," the 80 top-viewed YouTube videos and their viewing statistics (eg, views, likes, and comments) were collected. Videos that were non-English, unrelated to infertility, or had age restrictions were excluded. Content analysis was used to examine videos, employing a coding rubric that measured the presence or absence of video codes related to purpose, tone, and demographic and fertility characteristics (eg, sex, parity, stage of fertility treatment).
A total of 59 videos, with a median of 156,103 views, met the inclusion criteria and were categorized into 35 personal videos (35/59, 59%) and 24 informational-educational videos (24/59, 41%). Personal videos did not differ significantly from informational-educational videos on number of views, dislikes, subscriptions driven, or shares. However, personal videos had significantly more likes (P<.001) and comments (P<.001) than informational-educational videos. The purposes of the videos were treatment outcomes (33/59, 56%), sharing information (30/59, 51%), emotional aspects of infertility (20/59, 34%), and advice to others (6/59, 10%). The tones of the videos were positive (26/59, 44%), neutral (25/59, 42%), and mixed (8/59, 14%); there were no videos with negative tone. No videos contained only male posters. Videos with a positive tone did not differ from neutral videos in number of views, dislikes, subscriptions driven, or shares; however, positive videos had significantly more likes (P<.001) and comments (P<.001) than neutral videos. A majority (21/35, 60%) of posters of personal videos shared a pregnancy announcement.
YouTube is a source of both technical and personal experience-based information about infertility. However, videos that include personal experiences may elicit greater viewer engagement. Positive videos and stories of treatment success may provide hope to viewers but could also create and perpetuate unrealistic expectations about the success rates of fertility treatment.
不孕不育患者经常利用互联网查找与生育相关的信息,并从处于相似情况的人群中获取支持。YouTube越来越多地被用作健康相关信息的来源,可能会影响健康决策。目前尚无研究调查YouTube上与不孕不育相关视频的内容。
本研究的目的是(1)描述YouTube上观看量高的不孕不育相关视频的内容,以及(2)确定与观众偏好相关的视频特征。
使用搜索词“不孕不育”,收集了YouTube上观看量最高的80个视频及其观看统计数据(如观看次数、点赞数和评论数)。排除非英语、与不孕不育无关或有年龄限制的视频。采用内容分析法对视频进行审查,使用一个编码量表来衡量与目的、语气以及人口统计学和生育特征(如性别、生育次数、生育治疗阶段)相关的视频编码的有无。
共有59个视频符合纳入标准,中位数观看次数为156,103次,分为35个个人视频(35/59,59%)和24个信息教育视频(24/59,41%)。个人视频在观看次数、不喜欢数、带动的订阅数或分享数方面与信息教育视频没有显著差异。然而,个人视频的点赞数(P<.001)和评论数(P<.001)明显多于信息教育视频。视频的目的包括治疗结果(33/59,56%)、分享信息(30/59,51%)、不孕不育的情感方面(20/59,34%)以及给他人的建议(6/59,10%)。视频的语气为积极(26/59,44%)、中性(25/59,42%)和混合(8/59,14%);没有负面语气的视频。没有视频仅包含男性发布者。语气积极的视频在观看次数、不喜欢数、带动的订阅数或分享数方面与中性视频没有差异;然而,积极视频的点赞数(P<.001)和评论数(P<.001)明显多于中性视频。大多数(21/35,60%)个人视频的发布者分享了怀孕公告。
YouTube是关于不孕不育的技术和基于个人经验的信息来源。然而,包含个人经历的视频可能会引起观众更大的参与度。积极的视频和治疗成功的故事可能会给观众带来希望,但也可能会对生育治疗的成功率产生并延续不切实际的期望。