Ortega Adrian, Rooper Isabel R, Massion Thomas, Azubuike Chidibiere, Lipman Lindsay D, Lakhtakia Tanvi, Camino Macarena Kruger, Parsons Leah M, Tack Emily, Alshurafa Nabil, Kay Matthew, Graham Andrea K
Center for Behavioral Intervention Technologies, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, 750 N. Lake Shore Dr., 10th Floor, Chicago, IL 60611, USA.
Department of Preventive Medicine, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, 680 N. Lake Shore Dr., Suite 1400, Chicago, IL 60611,USA.
Transl Behav Med. 2025 Jan 16;15(1). doi: 10.1093/tbm/ibaf009.
Digital interventions can leverage user data to predict their health behavior, which can improve users' ability to make behavioral changes. Presenting predictions (e.g. how much a user might improve on an outcome) can be nuanced considering their uncertainty. Incorporating predictions raises design-related questions, such as how to present prediction data in a concise and actionable manner.
We conducted co-design sessions with end-users of a digital binge-eating intervention to learn how users would engage with prediction data and inform how to present these data visually. We additionally sought to understand how prediction intervals would help users understand uncertainty in these predictions and how users would perceive their actual progress relative to their prediction.
We conducted interviews with 22 adults with recurrent binge eating and obesity. We showed prototypes of hypothetical prediction displays for 5 evidence-based behavior change strategies, with the predicted success of each strategy for reducing binge eating in the week ahead (e.g. selecting to work on self-image this week might lead to 4 fewer binges while mood might lead to 1 fewer). We used thematic analysis to analyze data and generate themes.
Users welcomed using prediction data, but wanted to maintain their autonomy and minimize negative feelings if they do not achieve their predictions. Although preferences varied, users generally preferred designs that were simple and helped them quickly compare prediction data across strategies.
Predictions should be presented in efficient, organized layouts and with encouragement. Future studies should empirically validate findings in practice.
The Clinical Trials Registration #: NCT06349460.
数字干预可以利用用户数据来预测他们的健康行为,这可以提高用户做出行为改变的能力。考虑到预测的不确定性,呈现预测结果(例如用户在某一结果上可能改善的程度)可能会很微妙。纳入预测会引发与设计相关的问题,比如如何以简洁且可操作的方式呈现预测数据。
我们与一种数字暴饮暴食干预措施的终端用户进行了协同设计会议,以了解用户将如何与预测数据互动,并为如何以视觉方式呈现这些数据提供参考。我们还试图了解预测区间将如何帮助用户理解这些预测中的不确定性,以及用户将如何看待他们相对于预测的实际进展。
我们对22名患有复发性暴饮暴食和肥胖症的成年人进行了访谈。我们展示了5种基于证据的行为改变策略的假设预测显示原型,以及每种策略在未来一周减少暴饮暴食的预测成功率(例如,本周选择致力于自我形象改善可能会使暴饮暴食次数减少4次,而改善情绪可能会使次数减少1次)。我们使用主题分析来分析数据并生成主题。
用户欢迎使用预测数据,但希望保持自主权,并在未达到预测时尽量减少负面情绪。尽管偏好各不相同,但用户通常更喜欢简单且能帮助他们快速比较不同策略预测数据的设计。
预测应以高效、有条理的布局并带有鼓励性地呈现。未来的研究应在实践中对研究结果进行实证验证。
临床试验注册号:NCT06349460。