Robb Katharine, Uribe Pablo, Dickens Eleanor, Marcoux Ashley, Creighton Jessica, de Jong Jorrit
Bloomberg Harvard City Leadership Initiative, Harvard Kennedy School, 79 JFK Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2025 Feb 26;22(3):341. doi: 10.3390/ijerph22030341.
Creating and sustaining safe, healthy urban environments requires active collaboration between residents and local governments. Public safety and the upkeep of public spaces depend, in a large part, on residents' reports of crime and service needs. However, in underserved areas, factors such as urban decay, inadequate public services, and concentrated disadvantage have weakened these cooperative dynamics. This breakdown can exacerbate the underreporting of crime and service needs and deepen neighborhood inequalities. In Buffalo, NY, the city-led initiative "Clean Sweeps" works to reduce neighborhood disparities through rapid beautification and community outreach in targeted city blocks. The program aims to improve quality of life by reducing crime and blight while fostering greater community engagement. In an analysis of data from 77,955 matched properties (published elsewhere), we found that residents were more likely to report drug-related crimes (via 911) and blight-related service needs (via 311) compared to untreated properties in the 6 months following the Clean Sweep. In this study, we analyze data from 21 interviews with city staff and four focus groups with residents to explore how interventions in the social and physical environment of neighborhoods, like the Clean Sweep innovation, can influence residents' willingness to coproduce with local government. We identify improved responsiveness, trust, and self-efficacy as key mechanisms impacting residents' reporting behavior. The findings show how relatively simple environmental interventions paired with outreach can help create safer, healthier neighborhoods.
创建并维持安全、健康的城市环境需要居民与地方政府积极合作。公共安全和公共空间的维护在很大程度上取决于居民对犯罪行为及服务需求的报告。然而,在服务不足的地区,诸如城市衰败、公共服务不足和集中性劣势等因素削弱了这些合作动力。这种破裂会加剧犯罪行为和服务需求报告不足的情况,并加深社区不平等。在纽约州布法罗市,由市政府主导的“清洁清扫”倡议通过在目标城市街区进行快速美化和社区宣传来努力减少社区差距。该项目旨在通过减少犯罪和破败现象,同时促进更多社区参与,来提高生活质量。在对77955处匹配房产的数据进行分析(已在其他地方发表)时,我们发现,与“清洁清扫”之后6个月内未处理的房产相比,居民更有可能报告与毒品相关的犯罪行为(通过拨打911)以及与破败相关的服务需求(通过拨打311)。在本研究中,我们分析了来自对城市工作人员的21次访谈以及与居民的四个焦点小组的数据,以探讨对社区社会和物理环境的干预措施,如“清洁清扫”创新举措,如何影响居民与地方政府共同合作的意愿。我们确定改善响应能力、信任和自我效能感是影响居民报告行为的关键机制。研究结果表明,相对简单的环境干预措施与宣传相结合有助于创建更安全、更健康的社区。