Koubar Sahar H, Hatab Taha, Razzak Farah Abdul, Helal Imed, Ali Ala, Shebani Abdulhafid, Kaysi Saleh, Gunderman David, Al-Makki Akram, Davison Sara N
Division of Nephrology and Hypertension, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA.
Division of Nephrology and Hypertension, Department of Medicine, American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon.
Kidney Int Rep. 2025 Jan 16;10(4):1076-1086. doi: 10.1016/j.ekir.2025.01.011. eCollection 2025 Apr.
Conservative kidney management (CKM) is poorly developed and not easily accessible globally, especially in middle- and low-income countries. This study aimed to understand the perspectives of nephrologists on CKM and the barriers to its implementation in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region.
We conducted an online survey. Nephrologists were contacted through their local nephrology societies. Responses were divided into the following 3 groups as per the country's income classification by the World Bank: high-, middle-, and low-income.
A total of 336 surveys were analyzed (response rate: 34.28%). The mean age of participants was 43.3 ± 9.8 years; 50% were male, 91% practiced in urban settings, and 18% were affiliated with academic centers. Of the participants, 76% were from middle-income countries. Nearly 80% of the participants were aware of CKM, and 65% accepted CKM as a treatment modality for kidney failure. However, only 20% consistently offered CKM to their patients and only 16% had a formal CKM program at their institution. Among these, 12% had a multidisciplinary team and only 6% had formal CKM training. The major perceived barriers to CKM implementation were financial and resource constraints (37.7% and 32.7%, respectively). Cultural and religious barriers constituted 18.3% and 8.6%, respectively, and were similar among the 3 income groups.
Despite the significant awareness of CKM in the MENA region, its implementation remains poor. Key barriers include financial limitations, resource shortages, and a lack of training. Regional and national research is required to address these challenges and guide policies to improve CKM accessibility and implementation.
保守肾脏管理(CKM)在全球范围内发展不完善且不易获得,尤其是在中低收入国家。本研究旨在了解中东和北非(MENA)地区肾病学家对CKM的看法及其实施的障碍。
我们开展了一项在线调查。通过当地肾病学会联系肾病学家。根据世界银行对国家的收入分类,将回复分为以下3组:高收入、中等收入和低收入。
共分析了336份调查问卷(回复率:34.28%)。参与者的平均年龄为43.3±9.8岁;50%为男性,91%在城市地区执业,18%隶属于学术中心。参与者中,76%来自中等收入国家。近80%的参与者知晓CKM,65%接受CKM作为肾衰竭的一种治疗方式。然而,只有20%的人始终为其患者提供CKM,只有16%的机构有正式的CKM项目。其中,12%有一个多学科团队,只有6%有正式的CKM培训。CKM实施的主要感知障碍是财务和资源限制(分别为37.7%和32.7%)。文化和宗教障碍分别占18.3%和8.6%,在3个收入组中相似。
尽管中东和北非地区对CKM有显著的认知,但其实施情况仍然不佳。主要障碍包括资金限制、资源短缺和缺乏培训。需要进行区域和国家层面的研究来应对这些挑战,并指导政策以提高CKM的可及性和实施。