Ciss Mamadou, Giacomini Alessandra, Diouf Mame Nahé, Delabouglise Alexis, Mesdour Asma, Garcia Garcia Katherin, Muñoz Facundo, Cardinale Eric, Lo Mbargou, Gaye Adji Marème, Fall Mathioro, Ndiaye Khady, Fall Assane Gueye, Cetre-Sossah Catherine, Apolloni Andrea
Laboratoire National de l'Elevage et de Recherches Vétérinaires (ISRA-LNERV), Institut Sénégalais de Recherches Agricoles, Dakar-Hann BP 2057, Senegal.
CIRAD, UMR ASTRE, Montpellier, France.
Transbound Emerg Dis. 2023 Oct 12;2023:1880493. doi: 10.1155/2023/1880493. eCollection 2023.
Livestock mobility, particularly that of small and large ruminants, is one of the main pillars of production and trade in West Africa: livestock is moved around in search of better grazing or sold in markets for domestic consumption and for festival-related activities. These movements cover several thousand kilometers and have the capability of connecting the whole West African region, thus facilitating the diffusion of many animal and zoonotic diseases. Several factors shape mobility patterns even in normal years and surveillance systems need to account for such changes. In this paper, we present an approach based on temporal network theory to identify possible sentinel locations, i.e., locations where pathogens circulation can be detected in the early phase of the epidemic (before the peak), using two indicators: (i.e., the probability of being reached by the disease) and (i.e., the time of first arrival of the disease). Using these indicators in our structural analysis of the changing network enabled us to identify a set of nodes that could be used in an early warning system. As a case study, we simulated the introduction of transboundary animal diseases in Senegal and used data taken from 2020 Sanitary certificates ( (LPS)) issued by the Senegalese Veterinary Services to reconstruct the national mobility network. Our analysis showed that a static approach can significantly overestimate the speed and the extent of disease propagation, whereas temporal analysis revealed that the and of the different administrative departments (used as nodes of the mobility network) change over the course of the year. For this reason, several sets of sentinel nodes were identified in different periods of the year, underlining the role of temporality in shaping patterns of disease diffusion.
牲畜流动,尤其是小型和大型反刍动物的流动,是西非生产和贸易的主要支柱之一:牲畜四处迁移以寻找更好的牧场,或在市场上出售以供国内消费和用于与节日相关的活动。这些迁移行程达数千公里,能够连接整个西非地区,从而促进许多动物疾病和人畜共患疾病的传播。即使在正常年份,也有几个因素影响着流动模式,监测系统需要考虑到这些变化。在本文中,我们提出了一种基于时间网络理论的方法,使用两个指标来确定可能的哨兵地点,即在疫情早期阶段(高峰期之前)能够检测到病原体传播的地点:(即疾病到达的概率)和(即疾病首次到达的时间)。在对不断变化的网络进行结构分析时使用这些指标,使我们能够确定一组可用于预警系统的节点。作为一个案例研究,我们模拟了塞内加尔跨境动物疾病的传入,并使用塞内加尔兽医服务局颁发的2020年卫生证书((LPS))中的数据重建了国家流动网络。我们的分析表明,静态方法可能会显著高估疾病传播的速度和范围,而时间分析表明,不同行政部门(用作流动网络的节点)的和在一年中会发生变化。因此,在一年中的不同时期确定了几组哨兵节点,突出了时间性在塑造疾病传播模式中的作用。