Moon Jordan W, Johnson Kathryn A, Case Brendan, Padgett R Noah, Johnson Byron R, VanderWeele Tyler J
Centre for Culture and Evolution, Brunel University of London, Uxbridge, UK.
Psychology Department, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ, USA.
Sci Rep. 2025 Apr 30;15(1):14819. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-98796-1.
Religion is an integral part of everyday life for billions of people, yet little is known about the developmental antecedents of religious belief outside of Western cultures. Using data from over 200,000 individuals across 22 countries, we evaluate several childhood predictors of belief in God, gods, and spiritual forces (Belief in God) in adulthood. We hypothesized that these childhood experiences, personal attributes, and familial or social circumstances would have meaningful and varied associations with Belief in God as adults, with the strength of these associations differing by country, reflecting diverse cultural influences. Most candidate predictors (e.g., parental marital status, childhood socioeconomic status, abuse, being an outsider, and immigration) were associated with Belief in God in some countries but with substantial variation. However, when pooled across countries, only childhood religious service attendance, birth cohort, and gender were significant predictors. Yet there was important variation even for these predictors, and no predictor had a consistent association across all countries. Though this cross-sectional design is limited in allowing causal inference, results provide insights into early-life experiences that might contribute to adults' Belief in God. The heterogeneity of results highlights the importance of considering any childhood predictor within its social and cultural context.
宗教是数十亿人日常生活中不可或缺的一部分,但对于西方文化之外宗教信仰的发展前身却知之甚少。我们利用来自22个国家的20多万人的数据,评估了成年后对上帝、神灵和精神力量信仰(对上帝的信仰)的几个童年预测因素。我们假设,这些童年经历、个人特质以及家庭或社会环境,成年后会与对上帝的信仰产生有意义且多样的关联,这些关联的强度因国家而异,反映出不同的文化影响。大多数候选预测因素(例如,父母婚姻状况、童年社会经济地位、虐待、成为局外人以及移民)在一些国家与对上帝的信仰有关联,但存在很大差异。然而,当汇总所有国家的数据时,只有童年参加宗教仪式、出生队列和性别是显著的预测因素。即便对于这些预测因素,也存在重要差异,而且没有一个预测因素在所有国家都有一致的关联。尽管这种横断面设计在进行因果推断方面存在局限性,但研究结果为可能促成成年人对上帝信仰的早期生活经历提供了见解。结果的异质性凸显了在其社会和文化背景下考虑任何童年预测因素的重要性。