Gacheru Margaret, Mauro Christine, Skritskaya Natalia, Alston Nicole, Reynolds Charles F, Simon Naomi, Zisook Sidney, Lebowitz Barry, Shear M Katherine
Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University.
Center for Prolonged Grief, Columbia School of Social Work.
Cogn Behav Pract. 2025 Feb;32(1):44-55. doi: 10.1016/j.cbpra.2024.05.004. Epub 2024 Jul 30.
Prolonged grief disorder (PGD) is a condition of persistent, intense grief and PGD-targeted psychotherapy (PGDT) is an efficacious treatment. This study aimed to compare participants with PGD who self-identified as Black versus White, with respect to baseline features and response to PGDT. We performed a secondary data analysis of 55 Black and 455 White adults from two randomized clinical trials. Racial differences in baseline features were examined using Chi-squared and T-tests. We compared assessment completion and treatment response rates (PGDT vs. no PGDT) by race and evaluated posttreatment self-reported measures using linear models. There were racial differences in the cause of death, relation to the deceased, and taking comfort in religion. Black participants had similar ratings to their counterparts on impairment and grief severity at baseline. However, they had higher scores on a baseline measure of typical grief-related beliefs. Both racial groups had significantly greater response rates to PGDT than the comparison treatment. Similarly, PGDT resulted in lower posttreatment impairment than the comparison treatment for both racial groups. However, only the White participants had a difference in posttreatment grief severity between the treatment groups. This study supports the idea that PGD characteristics are similar in Black and White treatment seeking individuals, and that Black and White participants display improvement in response to PGDT.
持续性悲伤障碍(PGD)是一种持续强烈悲伤的病症,而针对PGD的心理治疗(PGDT)是一种有效的治疗方法。本研究旨在比较自我认定为黑人与白人的PGD参与者在基线特征和对PGDT的反应方面的差异。我们对来自两项随机临床试验的55名黑人和455名白人成年人进行了二次数据分析。使用卡方检验和t检验检查基线特征的种族差异。我们按种族比较了评估完成率和治疗反应率(PGDT与非PGDT),并使用线性模型评估了治疗后自我报告的测量结果。在死亡原因、与死者的关系以及从宗教中获得慰藉方面存在种族差异。黑人参与者在基线时的损伤和悲伤严重程度方面与白人参与者的评分相似。然而,他们在典型悲伤相关信念的基线测量上得分更高。两个种族群体对PGDT的反应率均显著高于对照治疗。同样,对于两个种族群体,PGDT导致的治疗后损伤低于对照治疗。然而,只有白人参与者在治疗组之间的治疗后悲伤严重程度存在差异。本研究支持这样一种观点,即寻求治疗的黑人和白人个体中PGD的特征相似,并且黑人和白人参与者对PGDT的反应均有改善。