Pang Siyuan, Concannon Elizabeth, Higgins Martin, Drummond Katharine, Gearing Peter, Devine Maxim, Tiong Albert, Ramakrishnan Anand, Fox Carly
Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, The Royal Melbourne Hospital, Parkville, Victoria, Australia.
Department of Surgery, The Royal Melbourne Hospital, University of Melbourne, Parkville, Victoria, Australia.
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2025 Sep;173(3):552-565. doi: 10.1002/ohn.1290. Epub 2025 May 5.
Osteoradionecrosis (ORN) is a recognized complication of radiotherapy. However, calvarial ORN (ORNC) following treatment for cutaneous malignancies is poorly understood. Shedding light on the limited evidence to date, this study aims to summarize existing evidence and highlight the research gaps.
PubMed and Embase.
A systematic search of PubMed and Embase was conducted up to May 2024, using relevant keywords to identify papers on ORNC. Data on the definition, incidence, risk factors, radiotherapy parameters, diagnostic methods, and management strategies were collected.
Twenty articles reporting on 42 ORNC patients were identified, revealing relatively poor data quality. There remains no consensus on a definition of ORNC. Patient- and disease-related risk factors have been inconsistently documented. No conclusion could be reached regarding thresholds for radiation dose delivery, as only seven studies reported the total radiation dose, with a mean of 58.9 Gy. Twenty-five (60%) cases managed with wound care and antibiotics demonstrated a spectrum of success rates, while 90% of surgically managed ORNC wounds healed at various follow-up points, ranging from 6 weeks to 9 years.
This study proposes an ORNC-specific definition and reporting standard through comparison with mandibular ORN. This will help generate valuable data, guiding the development of an ORNC-specific treatment protocol and clinical decision-making in managing this debilitating side effect of radiotherapy.
骨放射性坏死(ORN)是放射治疗公认的并发症。然而,皮肤恶性肿瘤治疗后颅骨ORN(ORNC)的情况却鲜为人知。鉴于目前有限的证据,本研究旨在总结现有证据并突出研究空白。
PubMed和Embase。
截至2024年5月,对PubMed和Embase进行了系统检索,使用相关关键词识别关于ORNC的论文。收集了有关定义、发病率、危险因素、放射治疗参数、诊断方法和管理策略的数据。
共识别出20篇报告42例ORNC患者的文章,数据质量相对较差。对于ORNC的定义尚未达成共识。患者和疾病相关的危险因素记录不一。由于只有7项研究报告了总放射剂量,平均为58.9 Gy,因此无法就放射剂量阈值得出结论。25例(60%)采用伤口护理和抗生素治疗的病例成功率不一,而90%接受手术治疗的ORNC伤口在6周至9年的不同随访时间点愈合。
本研究通过与下颌骨ORN比较,提出了ORNC特异性的定义和报告标准。这将有助于生成有价值的数据,指导制定ORNC特异性治疗方案以及针对这种放疗致残副作用的临床决策。