Peters Josh P, Sönnichsen Frank D, Hövener Jan-Bernd, Pravdivtsev Andrey N
Section Biomedical Imaging, Molecular Imaging North Competence Center (MOIN CC), Department of Radiology and Neuroradiology, University Hospital Schleswig-Holstein (UKSH), Kiel University, Kiel, Germany.
Otto Diels Institute for Organic Chemistry, Kiel University, Kiel, Germany.
NMR Biomed. 2025 Jun;38(6):e70046. doi: 10.1002/nbm.70046.
Novel methods and technology drive the rapid advances of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). The primary objective of developing novel hardware is to improve sensitivity and reliability (and possibly reduce cost). Automation has made NMR much more convenient, but it may lead to trusting the algorithms without regular checks. In this contribution, we analyzed the signal and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) as a function of the receiver gain (RG) for H, H, C, and N nuclei on five spectrometers. On a 1 T benchtop spectrometer (Spinsolve, Magritek), the SNR showed the expected increase as a function of RG. Still, the H and C signal amplitudes deviated by up to 50% from supposedly RG-independent signal intensities. On 7, 9.4, 11.7, and 14.1 T spectrometers (Avance Neo, Bruker), the signal intensity increases linearly with RG as expected, but surprisingly, a drastic drop of SNR is observed for some X-nuclei and fields. For example, while RG = 18 provided a C SNR similar to that at a maximum RG of 101 at 9.4 T, at RG = 20.2, the determined SNR was 32% lower. The SNR figures are strongly system and resonance frequency dependent. Our findings suggest that NMR users should test the specific spectrometer behavior to obtain optimum SNR for their experiments, as automatic RG adjustment does not account for the observed SNR characteristics. In addition, we provide a method to estimate optimal settings for thermally and hyperpolarized samples of a chosen concentration, polarization, and flip angle, which provide a high SNR and avoid ADC-overflow artefacts.
新颖的方法和技术推动了核磁共振(NMR)的快速发展。开发新型硬件的主要目标是提高灵敏度和可靠性(并可能降低成本)。自动化使核磁共振更加便捷,但可能导致在没有定期检查的情况下依赖算法。在本论文中,我们分析了五台光谱仪上氢、碳、氮原子核的信号及信噪比(SNR)与接收机增益(RG)的函数关系。在一台1T的台式光谱仪(Spinsolve,Magritek)上,信噪比随接收机增益的增加呈现出预期的增长。然而,氢和碳信号幅度与假定的与接收机增益无关的信号强度相比,偏差高达50%。在7T、9.4T、11.7T和14.1T的光谱仪(Avance Neo,布鲁克)上,信号强度如预期那样随接收机增益线性增加,但令人惊讶的是,对于某些原子核和磁场,观察到信噪比急剧下降。例如,在9.4T时,当接收机增益为18时,测得的碳信噪比与接收机增益最大为101时相似,但当接收机增益为20.2时,测得的信噪比降低了32%。信噪比数值强烈依赖于系统和共振频率。我们的研究结果表明,核磁共振用户应测试特定光谱仪的性能,以便为其实验获得最佳信噪比,因为自动接收机增益调整并未考虑到观察到的信噪比特性。此外,我们提供了一种方法,用于估计选定浓度、极化和翻转角的热极化和超极化样品的最佳设置,该设置可提供高信噪比并避免模数转换器溢出伪影。