Shiozawa Takuma, Yamaguchi Sosei, Igarashi Momoka, Ogawa Makoto, Abe Makiko, Yasuma Naonori, Kawaguchi Takayuki, Fujii Chiyo
Department of Mental Health and Psychiatric Nursing, Graduate School of Health Care Sciences, Institute of Science Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan.
Department of Community Mental Health & Law, National Institute of Mental Health, National Center of Neurology and Psychiatry, Tokyo, Japan.
Int J Ment Health Nurs. 2025 Jun;34(3):e70049. doi: 10.1111/inm.70049.
Several core outcome sets (COS) have been developed in the field of mental health; however, the specific outcome domains that should be prioritised in community mental health research remain unclear. This study aimed to identify the key outcome domains for community mental health research in Japan, as determined by multiple stakeholders. First, a comprehensive list of outcome domains was compiled by scoping reviews, focus group interviews, and web-based questionnaire surveys. This was followed by two rounds of preliminary surveys with multiple stakeholders. Finally, three rounds of a web-based Delphi survey were conducted to determine the most important outcome domains of community mental health research in Japan. A total of 96 outcome domains were evaluated by 297 participants, with a response rate of 93.6%. This study identified 24 outcome domains that are essential for community mental health research in Japan. These 24 domains, which reached a consensus, included aspects related to comprehensive symptom assessment and personal recovery. Given that community care serves patients with diverse illnesses, identifying outcome domains that are broadly applicable across different community care settings rather than being limited to specific conditions is critical for future research. The study also highlights differences in perspectives among stakeholders regarding the importance of various outcomes. Despite these differences, several outcome domains have been recognised as being significantly important in the overall consensus. Trial Registration: University Hospital Medical Information Network (UMIN) Clinical Trials Registry: UMIN000044680.
在心理健康领域已经制定了几个核心结局集(COS);然而,社区心理健康研究中应优先考虑的具体结局领域仍不明确。本研究旨在确定由多个利益相关者确定的日本社区心理健康研究的关键结局领域。首先,通过范围综述、焦点小组访谈和基于网络的问卷调查编制了一份全面的结局领域清单。随后对多个利益相关者进行了两轮初步调查。最后,进行了三轮基于网络的德尔菲调查,以确定日本社区心理健康研究中最重要的结局领域。共有297名参与者对96个结局领域进行了评估,回复率为93.6%。本研究确定了24个对日本社区心理健康研究至关重要的结局领域。这些达成共识的24个领域包括与综合症状评估和个人康复相关的方面。鉴于社区护理服务于患有各种疾病的患者,确定广泛适用于不同社区护理环境而非局限于特定病症的结局领域对未来研究至关重要。该研究还突出了利益相关者在各种结局重要性方面的观点差异。尽管存在这些差异,但在总体共识中,几个结局领域已被认为具有显著重要性。试验注册:大学医院医学信息网络(UMIN)临床试验注册中心:UMIN000044680。