Janssen Bernadette M, Mathijssen Jolanda J P, Van Bakel Hedwig J A
TRANZO - Scientific Center for Care and Wellbeing, Tilburg University, PO BOX 90153, 5000 LE Tilburg, The Netherlands.
Sterk Huis, PO Box 10139, 5000 JC Tilburg, The Netherlands.
Child Youth Care Forum. 2025;54(3):787-815. doi: 10.1007/s10566-024-09837-1. Epub 2024 Nov 19.
Given the impact of growing up in vulnerable families on opportunities in life and the large numbers of families with severe parenting and child functioning problems who repeatedly receive some form of youth care, it is important to investigate the long-term outcomes of the provided care.
This study aimed to investigate whether outcomes endure over a longer period of time, by exploring the effects of family-focused youth care on child, parental and family functioning at the end of care and at follow-up moments.
A systematic search was conducted in three databases (Psycinfo, Web of Science and ERIC), using search terms matching youth care and long-term effects. Effects between start and end of care, between end and follow up moments and between start and follow up moments on child, parent and family functioning were systematically mapped out.
Twenty-six articles were included describing effects of family-focused youth care at post treatment and at least one follow-up moment. The results demonstrated positive outcomes in short and longer term as improvement was found in child, parent and family functioning at the end of care and follow-up moments.
Despite the positive outcomes, determining long-term effects of youth care turned out to be difficult, as most studies organize follow-up moments within one year of the end of care. Moreover, there may also be an intertwined effect of the provided and possible follow-up care. More longitudinal research with follow-up moments over multiple years is required to investigate the durability of outcomes.
鉴于在弱势家庭中成长对人生机遇的影响,以及大量存在严重育儿和儿童功能问题且反复接受某种形式青少年照护的家庭,研究所提供照护的长期结果很重要。
本研究旨在通过探讨以家庭为中心的青少年照护在照护结束时及随访阶段对儿童、父母及家庭功能的影响,来调查结果是否能在更长时期内持续存在。
在三个数据库(Psycinfo、科学引文索引和教育资源信息中心)中进行系统检索,使用与青少年照护和长期影响相匹配的检索词。系统梳理了照护开始与结束之间、结束与随访阶段之间以及开始与随访阶段之间对儿童、父母及家庭功能的影响。
纳入了26篇文章,描述了以家庭为中心的青少年照护在治疗后及至少一个随访阶段的影响。结果表明,短期和长期均有积极结果,因为在照护结束时及随访阶段,儿童、父母及家庭功能均有改善。
尽管有积极结果,但确定青少年照护的长期影响结果证明很困难,因为大多数研究在照护结束后一年内安排随访阶段。此外,所提供的照护与可能的后续照护之间可能也存在相互交织的影响。需要开展更多有多年随访阶段的纵向研究,以调查结果的持续性。