Marcus Kanchan, Huckel-Schneider Carmen, Killedar Anagha, Balasubramanian Madhan, Rudman Arash, Sohn Woosung, Sivaprakash Prithivi, Norris Sarah, Liston Graeme, Wilson Naomi, Clarke Kara, Wilson Andrew
Leeder Centre for Health Policy, Economics and Data, School of Public Health, The University of Sydney, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
Health Care Management, College of Business Government and Law, Flinders University, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2025 Aug;53(4):424-441. doi: 10.1111/cdoe.13044. Epub 2025 May 20.
Tooth decay is a leading cause of total disease burden among Australian children. In 2019, the state government of New South Wales, Australia implemented the Primary School Mobile Dental Program (PSMDP) across five local health districts. Understanding stakeholder satisfaction of the PSMDP is an important measure of quality, to determine appropriateness as relevant to the needs of populations. The aim of the study was to explore parent/caregiver and provider attitudes, experiences, and perceptions of the PSMDP.
This study reports on the qualitative component of a mixed methods study examining parent/caregiver and provider (oral health staff) experiences of the program. Two of the five local health districts were selected for study sampling. Parents/caregivers were recruited using flyers administered via schools and oral health teams. Interviews were conducted between 2022 and 2023. The interviews lasted 20-60 min, were recorded, and transcribed verbatim. A critical realist lens was applied, and thematic analysis was conducted. Data saturation was achieved, and bias was reduced through member checking, researcher reflexivity, and team triangulation of the data.
In total, 79 individuals (58 parents/caregivers and 21 providers) were interviewed. Analysis revealed six key themes: (1) oral healthcare access, (2) informed consent, (3) parental attendance, (4) rewarding experiences, (5) operational barriers, and (6) communication clarity. The PSMDP promoted oral healthcare access while some parents/caregivers reported informed consent challenges. Providers cited rewarding experiences but face operational barriers including time constraints. Stakeholders diverged on parental attendance at school dental appointments, and most importantly, parents/caregivers requested follow-up communication clarity and coordination, particularly in feedback letters.
Qualitative findings identified generally positive attitudes and experiences with the PSMDP, and implications have been identified that would support the scale-up and sustainability of the PSMDP across the state. Study insights could be useful for similar programs, such as extending the attendance time per child, giving greater consideration to parental involvement, and improving communication and follow-up coordination.
龋齿是澳大利亚儿童总体疾病负担的主要原因。2019年,澳大利亚新南威尔士州政府在五个地方卫生区实施了小学流动牙科项目(PSMDP)。了解利益相关者对PSMDP的满意度是衡量质量的一项重要指标,以确定其是否符合人群需求。本研究的目的是探讨家长/照顾者以及提供者对PSMDP的态度、经历和看法。
本研究报告了一项混合方法研究的定性部分,该研究考察了家长/照顾者以及提供者(口腔卫生工作人员)对该项目的体验。从五个地方卫生区中选取了两个进行研究抽样。通过学校和口腔卫生团队发放传单招募家长/照顾者。访谈于2022年至2023年期间进行。访谈持续20 - 60分钟,进行了录音并逐字转录。采用批判实在论视角并进行了主题分析。实现了数据饱和,并通过成员核对、研究者反思以及数据的团队三角互证减少了偏差。
总共采访了79人(58名家长/照顾者和21名提供者)。分析揭示了六个关键主题:(1)口腔医疗服务可及性,(2)知情同意,(3)家长出勤情况,(4)有益体验,(5)操作障碍,以及(6)沟通清晰度。PSMDP促进了口腔医疗服务可及性,而一些家长/照顾者报告了知情同意方面的挑战。提供者提到了有益体验,但面临包括时间限制在内的操作障碍。利益相关者在家长参加学校牙科预约方面存在分歧,最重要的是,家长/照顾者要求后续沟通更加清晰和协调,尤其是在反馈信方面。
定性研究结果表明,对PSMDP总体持积极态度并有着积极体验,同时已确定了一些影响因素,这些因素将支持PSMDP在全州范围内的扩大实施和可持续发展。研究见解可能对类似项目有用,比如延长每个孩子的就诊时间、更多地考虑家长参与以及改善沟通和后续协调。