Örüm Dilek, Abuş Sabri, Kapıcı Yaşar
Department of Psychiatry, Elazig Fethi Sekin City Hospital, Elazig, Türkiye.
Faculty of Medicine, Department of Cardiology, Adiyaman University, Adıyaman, Türkiye.
Sci Rep. 2025 May 21;15(1):17558. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-93701-2.
Cardiologists' attitudes towards the patients with panic attack (PA) symptoms can be affected by many variables. This study was aimed to examine the practices and attitudes of cardiologists actively practicing in Turkey through an internet-based survey. An internet-based, cross-sectional, and observational survey was administered to actively practicing adult cardiologists. The sample size was calculated (minimum 135 participants). The survey draft was created by the conductor of the study and the final version of the survey items was decided by psychiatrists and cardiologists. Cronbach's alpha based on standardized items of the survey in the pilot (0.747) and final samples (0.742) was calculated. The survey, which included the characteristics on the landing page, was delivered to participants working in the Turkey via WhatsApp and Yahoo groups. All analyses were performed using IBM SPSS Statistics version 26.0. Ethical approval and informed consent was obtained. One hundred forty-five participants (87 males (60.00%) and 58 females (40.00%); 89 cardiology resident (61.37%) and 56 cardiology specialist (38.63%)) were included in the study. In patients presenting with symptoms of PA, when no cardiac/organic etiology was detected, 83 (57.24%) of the cardiologists directly referred the patients to psychiatry, while 62 (42.76%) of them started the treatment themselves. The most common symptom in patients presenting with non-cardiac PA symptoms was palpitations (86.20%). The number of cardiologists who had experience in starting escitalopram with a preliminary diagnosis of panic disorder (PD) was 50 (31.00%). Forty-three (29.7%) of cardiologists thought that antidepressants (ADs) were addictive. Thirty-five (24.1%) of cardiologists thought that ADs caused forgetfulness. According to 61 cardiologists, ADs should be used in the morning, while according to 64 cardiologists, ADs should be used in the evening. Forty-four (30.3%) cardiologists did not think benzodiazepines were addictive. The number of cardiologists who thought that patients who admitted to any physician other than cardiology with PA symptoms should be routinely referred to cardiology was 71 (49.00%). The difference between PA and PD was not known to any of the participants (n = 145). While gender had a limited effect on the findings, it was found that being cardiology specialist or not had a significant relationship with many variables. Binary logistic regression analysis was used to predict approach in the presence of non-cardiac PA symptoms and five variables (specialization status, routine echocardiogram examination, minimum usage time of ADs, association of ADs with addiction, and routine cardiology consultation by a non-cardiologist) were included given their contribution to the model (sensitivity = 86.70%, specificity = 83.90%; Beginning block - 2 Log likelihood 197.961; Block one - 2 Log likelihood 100.083, Cox & Snell R = 0.491, Nagelkerke R = 0.659; Hosmer and Lemeshow Test p value 0.254; constant p = 0.001). Non-cardiac PA symptoms are detected in approximately one sixth of those who apply to cardiology outpatient clinics, and it is recommended that cardiologists refer these patients to psychiatry to be evaluated for PD and receive appropriate treatment. PD treatment is a teamwork, and collaboration between cardiology and psychiatry is an integral part of this process.
心脏病专家对有惊恐发作(PA)症状患者的态度可能受到多种因素影响。本研究旨在通过一项基于互联网的调查,考察在土耳其积极执业的心脏病专家的诊疗行为和态度。对积极执业的成年心脏病专家进行了一项基于互联网的横断面观察性调查。计算了样本量(至少135名参与者)。调查问卷初稿由研究负责人编制,最终版本的调查项目由精神科医生和心脏病专家确定。计算了基于试点样本(0.747)和最终样本(0.742)中调查问卷标准化项目的克朗巴哈系数。包含首页特征的调查问卷通过WhatsApp和雅虎群组发送给在土耳其工作的参与者。所有分析均使用IBM SPSS Statistics 26.0版本进行。获得了伦理批准并取得了知情同意。145名参与者(87名男性(60.00%)和58名女性(40.00%);89名心脏病学住院医师(61.37%)和56名心脏病学专家(38.63%))纳入了本研究。在出现PA症状的患者中,当未检测到心脏/器质性病因时,83名(57.24%)心脏病专家直接将患者转诊至精神科,而其中62名(42.76%)自行开始治疗。出现非心脏性PA症状的患者中最常见的症状是心悸(86.20%)。有以惊恐障碍(PD)初步诊断开始使用艾司西酞普兰经验的心脏病专家有50名(31.00%)。43名(29.7%)心脏病专家认为抗抑郁药(ADs)会上瘾。35名(24.1%)心脏病专家认为ADs会导致记忆力减退。61名心脏病专家认为ADs应在早晨使用,而64名心脏病专家认为ADs应在晚上使用。44名(30.3%)心脏病专家不认为苯二氮䓬类药物会上瘾。认为有PA症状且就诊于除心脏病科以外任何科室的患者应常规转诊至心脏病科的心脏病专家有71名(49.00%)。所有参与者(n = 145)均不了解PA和PD之间的区别。虽然性别对研究结果影响有限,但发现是否为心脏病学专家与许多变量存在显著关系。采用二元逻辑回归分析来预测在存在非心脏性PA症状时的处理方式,并纳入了五个变量(专业状态、常规超声心动图检查、ADs的最短使用时间、ADs与成瘾的关联以及非心脏病专家的常规心脏病学会诊),因为它们对模型有贡献(敏感性 = 86.70%,特异性 = 83.90%;初始块 - 2对数似然值197.961;第一个块 - 2对数似然值100.083,Cox & Snell R = 0.491,Nagelkerke R = 0.659;Hosmer和Lemeshow检验p值0.254;常数p = 0.001)。在申请心脏病门诊的患者中,约六分之一检测到非心脏性PA症状,建议心脏病专家将这些患者转诊至精神科,以便评估是否患有PD并接受适当治疗。PD治疗是一项团队工作,心脏病学和精神科之间的协作是这一过程不可或缺的一部分。