Diagnostic value of genetic and epigenetic biomarker panels for colorectal cancer detection: a systematic review.

PURPOSE

Exploration of effective screening methods is imperative to improve current screening for colorectal cancer (CRC). Our aim was to systematically search the literature to identify and assess the diagnostic accuracy of both genetic and epigenetic biomarker panels for CRC detection using liquid biopsies for circulating tumour DNA (ctDNA) from stool, blood, or urine.

METHODS

A systematic review was performed according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses (PRISMA) with searches in Medline, Embase, CENTRAL, and Web Of Science from inception up to March 20, 2025, using pre-defined keywords. Study quality assessment was performed using QUADAS-2 tool (Quality Assessment for Diagnostic Accuracy Studies 2). Primary and secondary outcomes were panel performance (sensitivity and specificity) for CRC, advanced precancerous lesions (APL), and staging of disease.

RESULTS

Forty-four studies were included. Exceptional performance for both CRC (sensitivity and specificity) and APL (sensitivity) was displayed by biomarker panels including methylated SDC2 with methylated SFRP1/2 (CRC: 91.5%/97.3%, APL: 89.2%) or methylated TFPI2 (CRC: 94.9%/98.1%, APL: 100%), and a 5-biomarker panel of mutational targets APC, Bat-26, KRAS, L-DNA, and p53 (CRC: 91.0%/93.0%, APL: 82.0%). Suboptimal APL sensitivities up to 57.0% were exhibited by Cologuard and variant panels (including KRAS, methylated BMP3, methylated NDRG4, FIT), and 47.8% for combinations including methylated SEPT9.

CONCLUSIONS

High-performance, candidate ctDNA biomarker panels with exceptional diagnostic accuracy for both CRC and APL have been identified. Further work should focus on the development of large-scale studies to justify their clinical implementation.