Davies-Barrett Anna M, Casna Maia, Inskip Sarah A
School of Archaeology and Ancient History, University of Leicester, Leicester, United Kingdom.
Faculty of Archaeology, Leiden University, Leiden, Netherlands.
PLoS One. 2025 May 22;20(5):e0324045. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0324045. eCollection 2025.
Despite current clinical knowledge of the risks associated with tobacco consumption, the bioarchaeological investigation of tobacco's effect on health in past populations remains woefully underexamined. This study explores the potential respiratory health implications of the rapid incorporation of tobacco-use into the everyday lives of English citizens during the post-medieval period. Adult skeletons from urban post-medieval St James's Gardens Burial Ground, Euston, London (N = 281; CE1789-1853) and rural post-medieval (N = 151; CE1500-1855) and medieval (N = 62; CE1150-1500) Barton-upon-Humber were examined. Individuals were assessed for tobacco consumption status using osteoarchaeological and biomolecular methods. Individuals were observed for bone changes related to inflammation within the maxillary sinuses and within the pleural/pulmonary regions. Statistical tests revealed a significant association between tobacco consumption and the presence of pulmonary/pleural inflammation in the Barton-upon-Humber post-medieval group. Tobacco consumers at Barton-upon-Humber were also more than twice as likely to present with maxillary sinusitis or pleural/pulmonary inflammation, although the results were not statistically significant. Differences between tobacco consumers and non-consumers in the London group were not apparent, but the odds of having maxillary sinusitis increased by two-fold in middle adults (compared to young adults) and lower socio-economic groups (compared to higher socio-economic groups). Significant differences in respiratory disease frequencies were apparent between rural and urban groups. The results highlight the complexity of factors affecting upper and lower respiratory disease, indicating the potential impacts of not only tobacco consumption, but household, environmental, and occupational air pollution, as well as poor water sanitation, on frequencies of respiratory disease in different population groups.
尽管目前临床上已了解与烟草消费相关的风险,但烟草对过去人群健康影响的生物考古学研究仍严重不足。本研究探讨了后中世纪时期烟草使用迅速融入英国公民日常生活对呼吸健康的潜在影响。对来自伦敦尤斯顿市后中世纪圣詹姆斯花园墓地(N = 281;公元1789 - 1853年)、农村后中世纪时期(N = 151;公元1500 - 1855年)以及中世纪(N = 62;公元1150 - 1500年)的亨伯河畔巴顿的成年骨骼进行了检查。使用骨考古学和生物分子方法评估个体的烟草消费状况。观察个体上颌窦以及胸膜/肺部区域与炎症相关的骨骼变化。统计检验显示,在亨伯河畔巴顿的后中世纪组中,烟草消费与肺部/胸膜炎症的存在之间存在显著关联。亨伯河畔巴顿的烟草消费者出现上颌窦炎或胸膜/肺部炎症的可能性也高出两倍多,尽管结果在统计学上并不显著。伦敦组中烟草消费者和非消费者之间的差异不明显,但中年成年人(与年轻成年人相比)以及社会经济地位较低的群体(与社会经济地位较高的群体相比)患上颌窦炎的几率增加了两倍。农村和城市群体之间呼吸系统疾病频率存在显著差异。结果突出了影响上、下呼吸道疾病的因素的复杂性,表明不仅烟草消费,而且家庭、环境和职业空气污染以及不良的水卫生条件,都可能对不同人群组的呼吸系统疾病频率产生潜在影响。