Toccalino Danielle, Chadambuka Cyndirela, Arruda-Caycho Isabel, Arora Navya, Powell Margaret, Quiñonez Carlos, Essue Beverley M
Institute of Health Policy, Management and Evaluation, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
BMJ Public Health. 2025 May 26;3(1):e001770. doi: 10.1136/bmjph-2024-001770. eCollection 2025.
Gender-based violence (GBV) is a significant public health concern affecting one in three women globally. GBV is deeply rooted in gender inequality and societal constructs of gender roles, which significantly contribute to its prevalence and impact on women. Injury to the head, face, and neck, including broken teeth and jaws, is common in GBV, as is dental neglect, indicating a role for dental care. However, the impact of maxillofacial injuries or poor oral health and the role dental professionals may play in supporting individuals experiencing GBV are often overlooked. This review aimed to explore the research question: What is known in the literature about the roles of dentistry in identifying and supporting individuals who have experienced GBV?
A search strategy including dental care and GBV-related text words and subject headings was developed and run across seven databases. Searches were not limited by date, location, or language. Articles were eligible for inclusion if they (1) described or evaluated provision of, need for, or outcomes of dental care; AND (2) focused on individuals who had experienced GBV aged 18+. Data were extracted from articles meeting inclusion criteria and narrative synthesis used to describe and synthesise findings.
84 articles met inclusion criteria, predominantly published in the United States and focused on dental care providers' knowledge, perceptions, and actions related to GBV. Only four identified articles looked at dental care interventions tailored to GBV. Individuals who experienced GBV were found to experience high rates of maxillofacial injury because of the violence. They also reported more oral health issues, negative perceptions of their teeth, and irregular dental visits than individuals who have not experienced GBV. Dental professionals were generally underprepared to support individuals experiencing GBV, but training interventions proved effective in increasing knowledge and competency. Overall, the literature supported a need for dental care in GBV and a tailored approach to supporting individuals who have experienced GBV.
GBV can have profound impacts on oral health. There is a lack of knowledge about GBV in dental settings and the need to include GBV in dental curricula and further training is often overlooked. Policies and mandatory guidelines are necessary to ensure that GBV education and training are integrated into dental care settings. Trauma-informed dental care, integration of dental care into GBV support settings, and broader awareness of GBV among dental care providers are also needed.
基于性别的暴力(GBV)是一个重大的公共卫生问题,全球三分之一的女性受其影响。GBV深深植根于性别不平等和性别角色的社会建构,这在很大程度上导致了其普遍性及其对女性的影响。在GBV中,头部、面部和颈部受伤,包括牙齿和颌骨骨折很常见,忽视牙齿护理的情况也很常见,这表明牙科护理能发挥作用。然而,颌面损伤或口腔健康不佳的影响以及牙科专业人员在支持遭受GBV的个人方面可能发挥的作用常常被忽视。本综述旨在探讨以下研究问题:关于牙科在识别和支持遭受GBV的个人方面的作用,文献中有哪些了解?
制定了一种搜索策略,包括牙科护理和与GBV相关的文本词及主题词,并在七个数据库中进行搜索。搜索不受日期、地点或语言限制。如果文章(1)描述或评估了牙科护理的提供、需求或结果;并且(2)关注18岁以上遭受GBV的个人,则符合纳入标准。从符合纳入标准的文章中提取数据,并使用叙述性综合分析来描述和综合研究结果。
84篇文章符合纳入标准,主要发表在美国,且聚焦于牙科护理提供者与GBV相关的知识、认知和行动。仅4篇已识别的文章研究了针对GBV的牙科护理干预措施。发现遭受GBV的个人因暴力而颌面受伤的比例很高。他们还报告说,与未遭受GBV的个人相比,他们有更多的口腔健康问题、对自己牙齿的负面看法以及不定期看牙的情况。牙科专业人员通常没有做好支持遭受GBV的个人的准备,但培训干预措施在增加知识和能力方面被证明是有效的。总体而言,文献支持在GBV中提供牙科护理以及采取量身定制的方法来支持遭受GBV的个人。
GBV会对口腔健康产生深远影响。在牙科环境中,对GBV缺乏了解,将GBV纳入牙科课程以及进一步培训的必要性常常被忽视。需要政策和强制性指南来确保将GBV教育和培训纳入牙科护理环境。还需要了解创伤情况的牙科护理、将牙科护理纳入GBV支持环境以及提高牙科护理提供者对GBV的更广泛认识。