Xiao Hongfei
Postdoctoral Research Station, Shenwan Hongyuan Securities Co., Ltd., Shanghai, China.
Faculty of Finance, City University of Macau, Macao, China.
PLoS One. 2025 Jun 2;20(6):e0322737. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0322737. eCollection 2025.
LSTM (Long Short-Term Memory Network) is currently extensively utilized for forecasting financial time series, primarily due to its distinct advantages in separating the long-term from the short-term memory information within a sequence. However, the experimental results presented in this paper indicate that LSTM may struggle to clearly differentiate between these two types of information. To overcome this limitation, we propose the ARMA-RNN-LSTM Hybrid Model, aimed at enhancing the separation between the long-term and short-term memory information on top of LSTM framework. The experiment in this paper is inspired by an observation: when LSTMs and RNNs are respectively used to forecast the same time series that contains only short-term memory information, LSTMs exhibit significantly lower forecasting accuracy than RNNs, and we attributed this to LSTMs potentially misclassifying some short-term memory information as long-term during forecasting process. Further, we speculate that this confusion might also arise when LSTMs are used to forecast the time series containing both the long-term and short-term memory information. To verify the aforementioned hypothesis and improve the forecasting accuracy for financial time series, this paper combines RNNs with LSTMs, proposing a method of ARMA-RNN-LSTM Hybrid Modelling, and conducts an experiment with stock index prices. Eventually, the experiment results show that the ARMA-RNN-LSTM Hybrid Model outperforms standalone RNNs and LSTMs in forecasting stock index series containing both long-term and short-term memory information, confirming that the ARMA-RNN-LSTM Hybrid Model has effectively enhanced the separation between the long-term and short-term memory information within sequence. This hybrid modelling approach has innovatively addressed the issue of the confusion between the long-term and the short-term memory information in a sequence during LSTM's forecasting process, improving the accuracy of forecasting financial time series, and demonstrates that neural network's forecasting errors is a area worth to explore in the future.
长短期记忆网络(LSTM)目前被广泛用于预测金融时间序列,主要是因为它在区分序列中的长期记忆信息和短期记忆信息方面具有独特优势。然而,本文给出的实验结果表明,LSTM可能难以清晰地区分这两种信息。为克服这一局限性,我们提出了ARMA-RNN-LSTM混合模型,旨在在LSTM框架之上增强长期记忆信息和短期记忆信息之间的区分。本文的实验灵感来源于一个观察结果:当分别使用LSTM和RNN预测仅包含短期记忆信息的同一时间序列时,LSTM的预测准确率显著低于RNN,我们将此归因于LSTM在预测过程中可能将一些短期记忆信息误分类为长期记忆信息。此外,我们推测,当使用LSTM预测同时包含长期记忆信息和短期记忆信息的时间序列时,也可能出现这种混淆。为验证上述假设并提高金融时间序列的预测准确率,本文将RNN与LSTM相结合,提出了一种ARMA-RNN-LSTM混合建模方法,并对股票指数价格进行了实验。最终,实验结果表明,ARMA-RNN-LSTM混合模型在预测同时包含长期记忆信息和短期记忆信息的股票指数序列方面优于单独的RNN和LSTM,证实了ARMA-RNN-LSTM混合模型有效地增强了序列中长短期记忆信息之间的区分。这种混合建模方法创新性地解决了LSTM预测过程中序列中长期记忆信息和短期记忆信息混淆的问题,提高了金融时间序列的预测准确率,并表明神经网络的预测误差是未来值得探索的一个领域。