Visani Elisa, Rossi Sebastiano Davide, Garofalo Gioacchino, Duran Dunja, Tangorra Melania, Mezzadri Marco, Buccino Giovanni
Fondazione IRCCS Istituto Neurologico Carlo Besta, Milan, Italy.
Università "Vita-Salute" San Raffaele di Milano - Dipartimento di Neuroscienze, Milan, Italy.
Front Psychol. 2025 May 20;16:1585897. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1585897. eCollection 2025.
Experimental evidence shows that the sensorimotor system is not only involved in performing actions but also in observing and understanding them, even when verbally described. The involvement of the sensorimotor system in processing action related language material is known as embodiment. Following this approach, language items presented in L1 and L2 should affect motor activity in the same manner.
This study aimed to investigate the involvement of motor system during the processing of L2 items in a combined behavioral and MEG study. Healthy Italian native speakers performed a semantic decision task on hand and foot actions presented by means of pictures or verbs expressed in English as L2.
Results showed slower hand reaction times and weaker suppression of Beta band power during the processing of hand-related pictures and verbs, as compared to foot-related pictures and verbs, thus suggesting shared neural mechanisms for semantic processing of visually and verbally presented items.
This in line with a similar study where Italian verbs were used as language items. However, while no dissimilarity was found in the modulation of the motor system during the processing of verbs presented in L1 and pictures depicting actions in the same category, here, when processing L2 verbs, reaction times were slower than when processing visually presented actions, thus implying an additional cost for processing L2 as compared to L1 verbal items.
We argue that these findings support embodiment, in that they can be explained by a similar, although stronger involvement of the sensorimotor system during the processing of L2 verbal items.
实验证据表明,感觉运动系统不仅参与执行动作,还参与观察和理解动作,即使是在进行口头描述时也是如此。感觉运动系统参与处理与动作相关的语言材料被称为具身化。按照这种方法,用第一语言(L1)和第二语言(L2)呈现的语言项目应该以相同的方式影响运动活动。
本研究旨在通过行为学和脑磁图(MEG)相结合的研究,调查运动系统在处理第二语言项目时的参与情况。健康的意大利母语者对以英语作为第二语言通过图片或动词呈现的手部和足部动作执行语义判断任务。
结果显示,与足部相关的图片和动词相比,在处理与手部相关的图片和动词时,手部反应时间更慢,β波段功率的抑制更弱,这表明视觉和语言呈现项目的语义处理存在共同的神经机制。
这与一项使用意大利动词作为语言项目的类似研究一致。然而,虽然在处理第一语言中呈现的动词和描绘同一类动作的图片时,未发现运动系统的调制存在差异,但在这里,在处理第二语言动词时,反应时间比处理视觉呈现的动作时更慢,这意味着与第一语言语言项目相比,处理第二语言存在额外的成本。
我们认为这些发现支持具身化,因为它们可以通过感觉运动系统在处理第二语言语言项目时类似但更强的参与来解释。