Chen Yuhuan, Dean Kara J, Fenske Gavin J, Murphy Sarah I, Gavelek Alexandra, Pouillot Régis, Van Doren Jane M, Dennis Sherri
Human Foods Program, U.S. Food and Drug Administration, College Park, Maryland, United States of America.
Goldbelt C6, LLC, Chesapeake, Virginia, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2025 Jun 4;20(6):e0322948. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0322948. eCollection 2025.
An outbreak of highly pathogenic avian influenza A, subtype H5N1, first reported in U.S. dairy cattle in March 2024, raised concerns of an emerging food safety threat from the virus in the milk supply. To support potential regulatory responses, we conducted a rapid assessment of the predicted risk to U.S. consumers of cow's milk with two complementary and parallel approaches: a "bottom-up" quantitative risk assessment model that integrated data on virus levels in milk, milk consumption, and dose response; and a "top-down" epidemiological analysis that linked current novel flu illness detection to the consumption of raw and pasteurized milk. The dynamic use of the approaches accommodated rapidly evolving data in a range of risk scenarios. The risk assessment model identified pasteurization as a critical control for H5N1 in milk and highlighted the need for i) the targeted sampling of bulk tank raw milk in affected states pre-pasteurization, ii) raw milk herd surveillance and sampling, and iii) a better understanding of ingestion as a route of H5N1 infections for humans. This novel approach and the findings from this study promoted informed decision-making in an evolving outbreak investigation. This methodology can be leveraged in the conduct of future risk assessments to address emerging pathogen outbreaks that impact the food supply.
2024年3月首次在美国奶牛中报告的高致病性甲型H5N1禽流感疫情引发了人们对牛奶供应中该病毒带来的新食品安全威胁的担忧。为支持潜在的监管应对措施,我们采用两种互补且并行的方法对美国消费者饮用牛奶的预测风险进行了快速评估:一种是“自下而上”的定量风险评估模型,该模型整合了牛奶中病毒水平、牛奶消费和剂量反应的数据;另一种是“自上而下”的流行病学分析,将当前新型流感疾病检测与生牛奶和巴氏杀菌牛奶的消费联系起来。这些方法的动态运用适应了一系列风险情景中快速变化的数据。风险评估模型确定巴氏杀菌是牛奶中H5N1的关键控制措施,并强调了以下几点的必要性:i)在受影响州对巴氏杀菌前的大容量罐生牛奶进行有针对性的采样,ii)对生牛奶畜群进行监测和采样,iii)更好地了解摄入作为人类感染H5N1的途径。这种新颖的方法以及本研究的结果促进了在不断演变的疫情调查中做出明智的决策。这种方法可用于未来的风险评估,以应对影响食品供应的新出现病原体疫情。