Mun KwangHo, Park Hye Jin
Department of Preventive Medicine, Eulji University School of Medicine, Daejeon, Korea.
Department of Medical Education, Eulji University School of Medicine, Daejeon, Korea.
Korean J Med Educ. 2025 Jun;37(2):219-224. doi: 10.3946/kjme.2025.336. Epub 2025 May 29.
Lecture-based teaching is widely used in preclinical medical education, offering a systematic way to deliver complex information efficiently. However, its effectiveness heavily relies on the instructional behaviors of lecturers. Despite its importance, limited research has explored the specific differences between effective and ineffective teaching behaviors perceived by students. This study aims to analyze these behaviors systematically to provide actionable insights for enhancing teaching competencies.
This study surveyed 92 first-year medical students to evaluate effective and ineffective teaching behaviors. A 30-item questionnaire was developed based on existing literature. Data analysis included descriptive statistics to rank teaching behaviors and chi-square tests to examine their correlations.
Effective behaviors included appropriate voice volume, clear pronunciation, error-free lecture materials, clear explanations of learning objectives, and humor. Ineffective behaviors were poor voice clarity, insufficient summarization, lack of follow-up session introductions, absence of online resources, and poor interaction. Significant relationships between effective and ineffective behaviors were observed in some items.
The study highlights those effective behaviors, such as recalling prior learning, utilizing materials, and engaging students, enhance learning outcomes. Faculty development should focus on avoiding ineffective behaviors for novice faculty and reinforcing effective ones for mid-career faculty to improve teaching quality in medical education.
基于讲座的教学在临床前医学教育中被广泛应用,它提供了一种系统的方式来高效传递复杂信息。然而,其有效性很大程度上依赖于讲师的教学行为。尽管其很重要,但针对学生所感知到的有效与无效教学行为之间的具体差异,相关研究却很有限。本研究旨在系统分析这些行为,为提高教学能力提供可操作的见解。
本研究对92名一年级医学生进行了调查,以评估有效和无效的教学行为。基于现有文献编制了一份包含30个条目的问卷。数据分析包括用于对教学行为进行排序的描述性统计以及用于检验其相关性的卡方检验。
有效行为包括适当的音量、清晰的发音、无错误的讲稿、对学习目标的清晰解释以及幽默。无效行为包括声音清晰度差、总结不足、缺乏后续课程介绍、没有在线资源以及互动性差。在一些项目中观察到了有效行为与无效行为之间的显著关系。
该研究强调,诸如回顾先前学习内容、利用材料以及吸引学生参与等有效行为能够提高学习效果。教师发展应侧重于让新手教师避免无效行为,并让处于职业生涯中期的教师强化有效行为,以提高医学教育的教学质量。