Hyde Jamie, King Eleanor, John Joseph, O'Flynn Kieran, Pearce Ian, McGrath John, Gray William K, Phull Manraj
Greener NHS, NHS England, London, UK.
University of Exeter Medical School, Exeter, UK.
BJU Int. 2025 Aug;136(2):198-207. doi: 10.1111/bju.16800. Epub 2025 Jun 5.
To present a narrative review of evidence to guide the delivery of high-quality, low-carbon urological care using a structured framework.
Academic and policy papers which outline actions focused on decarbonising urological care and surgical care more broadly were identified and reviewed. The 'STEPS to Low-Carbon Care' framework (an acronym for low-carbon care across 'Settings and Treatments, Efficiency, Prevention and System change') was then used to categorise and present the evidence-based decarbonisation actions, using the National Health Service in England as a case study.
Across all STEPS framework elements, tangible actions were identified alongside opportunities for future research and innovation. The evidence-based actions that were identified to transition to low-carbon care settings and treatments included tackling known carbon hotspots in operating theatres: anaesthetic gases, consumables and electricity use. Outside the operating theatre, urology pathway transformation through one-stop clinics, day-case surgery, appropriate use of virtual appointments and streamlined pathways demonstrated opportunities to reduce carbon emissions, with potential additional benefits in terms of cost, efficiencies, and patient outcome improvements. Key climate mitigation actions that support keeping people healthy were identified. There was a paucity of evidence demonstrating the implementation of climate change action as part of routine service delivery. Embedding sustainability across organisational processes and ways of working requires actions to upskill, engage and enable the workforce to deliver and to establish clinical leadership.
This review identified a range of interventions to decarbonise urological care, whilst highlighting a need for further research. Categorising the evidence according to components of the STEPS framework indicated the potential utility of this framework when determining unrealised decarbonisation opportunities in urology and more widely across healthcare. Delivering sustained and system-wide low-carbon urological care will require the collective action of all who design, deliver and influence patient care across the specialty and all urology patient pathways.
使用结构化框架对证据进行叙述性综述,以指导高质量、低碳泌尿外科护理的提供。
识别并综述了概述更广泛地关注泌尿外科护理和手术护理脱碳行动的学术和政策文件。然后使用“低碳护理步骤”框架(“环境与治疗、效率、预防和系统变革”中低碳护理的首字母缩写),以英国国民医疗服务体系为例,对基于证据的脱碳行动进行分类和呈现。
在所有步骤框架要素中,确定了切实可行的行动以及未来研究和创新的机会。确定的向低碳护理环境和治疗过渡的基于证据的行动包括解决手术室中已知的碳排放热点问题:麻醉气体、耗材和电力使用。在手术室之外,通过一站式诊所、日间手术、合理使用虚拟预约和简化流程对泌尿外科诊疗路径进行改造,显示出减少碳排放的机会,在成本、效率和改善患者结局方面可能还有额外的好处。确定了支持人们保持健康的关键气候缓解行动。缺乏证据表明将气候变化行动作为常规服务提供的一部分加以实施。将可持续性融入组织流程和工作方式需要采取行动提升员工技能、促使员工参与并使其能够提供服务,并建立临床领导力。
本综述确定了一系列使泌尿外科护理脱碳的干预措施,同时强调了进一步研究的必要性。根据“步骤”框架的组成部分对证据进行分类,表明该框架在确定泌尿外科以及更广泛医疗保健领域未实现的脱碳机会时具有潜在效用。提供持续且全系统的低碳泌尿外科护理将需要所有参与设计、提供和影响该专业所有患者护理及所有泌尿外科患者诊疗路径的人员共同采取行动。