He Lingfei, Wang Siyu, Chen Cheng, Wang Yaping, Fan Qingcheng, Chu Congying, Fan Lingzhong, Xu Junhai
College of Intelligence and Computing, Tianjin Key Laboratory of Cognitive Computing and Application, Tianjin University, Tianjin, China.
Brainnetome Center, Beijing, China.
Hum Brain Mapp. 2025 Jun 1;46(8):e70239. doi: 10.1002/hbm.70239.
Deep learning frameworks utilizing convolutional neural networks (CNNs) have frequently been used for brain age prediction and have achieved outstanding performance. Nevertheless, deep learning remains a black box as it is hard to interpret which brain parts contribute significantly to the predictions. To tackle this challenge, we first trained a lightweight, fully CNN model for brain age estimation on a large sample data set (N = 3054, age range = [8,80 years]) and tested it on an independent data set (N = 555, age range = [8,80 years]). We then developed an interpretable scheme combining network occlusion sensitivity analysis (NOSA) with a fine-grained human brain atlas to uncover the learned invariance of the model. Our findings show that the dorsolateral, dorsomedial frontal cortex, anterior cingulate cortex, and thalamus had the highest contributions to age prediction across the lifespan. More interestingly, we observed that different regions showed divergent patterns in their predictions for specific age groups and that the bilateral hemispheres contributed differently to the predictions. Regions in the frontal lobe were essential predictors in both the developmental and aging stages, with the thalamus remaining relatively stable and saliently correlated with other regional changes throughout the lifespan. The lateral and medial temporal brain regions gradually became involved during the aging phase. At the network level, the frontoparietal and the default mode networks show an inverted U-shape contribution from the developmental to the aging stages. The framework could identify regional contributions to the brain age prediction model, which could help increase the model interpretability when serving as an aging biomarker.
利用卷积神经网络(CNN)的深度学习框架经常被用于脑龄预测,并取得了出色的性能。然而,深度学习仍然是一个黑箱,因为很难解释哪些脑区对预测有显著贡献。为了应对这一挑战,我们首先在一个大样本数据集(N = 3054,年龄范围 = [8, 80岁])上训练了一个用于脑龄估计的轻量级全CNN模型,并在一个独立数据集(N = 555,年龄范围 = [8, 80岁])上进行了测试。然后,我们开发了一种可解释的方案,将网络遮挡敏感性分析(NOSA)与精细的人类脑图谱相结合,以揭示模型学习到的不变性。我们的研究结果表明,背外侧、背内侧额叶皮层、前扣带回皮层和丘脑在整个生命周期中对年龄预测的贡献最大。更有趣的是,我们观察到不同区域在对特定年龄组的预测中呈现出不同的模式,并且双侧半球对预测的贡献也不同。额叶区域在发育和衰老阶段都是重要的预测指标,丘脑在整个生命周期中保持相对稳定,并与其他区域变化显著相关。颞叶外侧和内侧区域在衰老阶段逐渐参与进来。在网络层面,额顶叶网络和默认模式网络从发育阶段到衰老阶段呈现出倒U形的贡献。该框架可以识别对脑龄预测模型的区域贡献,这在作为衰老生物标志物时有助于提高模型的可解释性。