Loganathan Tharani, Zaini Amirah Zafirah, Majid Hazreen Abdul
Centre for Epidemiology and Evidence-Based Practice, Department of Social and Preventive Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
School of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences, Health Sciences University, Parkwood Campus, Bournemouth, Dorset, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2025 Jun 10;20(6):e0326045. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0326045. eCollection 2025.
Malaysia provided COVID-19 vaccines for all residents, regardless of citizenship status. However, the extent of vaccine accessibility for migrant populations remains unclear, given the complex healthcare barriers they face. This study explored the barriers migrants faced in accessing COVID-19 vaccines and the measures taken to facilitate their access.
This qualitative study, conducted between April 2022 and February 2023, involved 32 purposively selected key informants from non-governmental organisations (7), international organisations (2), labour unions (2), healthcare providers (11) and migrant communities (10). Data were collected through in-depth, semi-structured, primarily individual interviews, and analysed using NVivo 12 Pro software following a six-phase thematic analysis: data familiarisation, code generation, theme identification, theme review, theme definition, and reporting.
Thematic analysis identified barriers-including legal and administrative challenges, digital exclusion, vaccine hesitancy, and logistical issues-and facilitators, such as mandatory vaccination policies, innovative delivery approaches, communication support, and community engagement. Substantial challenges arose from pervasive distrust in healthcare services, compounded by identity document requirements, roadblocks, and fears of immigration arrests. Digital appointment systems excluded many migrants due to language and literacy barriers, data privacy concerns, and the need for identity documents. While vaccine hesitancy among migrants was generally low, concerns were primarily driven by fears of immigration enforcement rather than vaccine safety. Despite vaccination being voluntary, mandatory requirements for digital vaccination certificates or negative COVID-19 test results strongly incentivised uptake. Employer support, driven by economic interests, played a critical role in promoting compliance with workplace vaccination mandates. Collaboration with non-governmental organisations and community partners proved pivotal, offering tailored health communication and building trust. Flexible vaccine delivery strategies, including a shift from centralised to outreach models near residences and workplaces, enhanced access, particularly for hard-to-reach populations.
Despite numerous challenges, Malaysia's vaccination efforts were largely successful due to innovative and collaborative delivery and communication strategies. To further improve health equity among marginalised populations, it is essential to enhance culturally sensitive training for frontline workers, strengthen employers' business ethics, and increase the involvement of trusted stakeholders.
马来西亚为所有居民提供新冠疫苗,无论其公民身份如何。然而,鉴于移徙人口面临复杂的医疗保健障碍,他们获取疫苗的程度仍不明确。本研究探讨了移徙者在获取新冠疫苗方面面临的障碍以及为便利其获取所采取的措施。
这项定性研究于2022年4月至2023年2月进行,涉及32名从非政府组织(7名)、国际组织(2名)、工会(2名)、医疗服务提供者(11名)和移徙社区(10名)中特意挑选的关键信息提供者。数据通过深入的、半结构化的、主要是个人访谈收集,并使用NVivo 12 Pro软件按照六个阶段的主题分析进行分析:数据熟悉、代码生成、主题识别、主题审查、主题定义和报告。
主题分析确定了障碍,包括法律和行政挑战、数字排斥、疫苗犹豫和后勤问题,以及促进因素,如强制疫苗接种政策、创新的接种方式、沟通支持和社区参与。对医疗服务普遍存在的不信任,再加上身份文件要求、路障以及对移民逮捕的恐惧,引发了诸多重大挑战。数字预约系统因语言和识字障碍、数据隐私问题以及对身份文件的需求而将许多移徙者排除在外。虽然移徙者中的疫苗犹豫情绪总体较低,但其担忧主要是由对移民执法的恐惧而非疫苗安全驱动的。尽管接种是自愿的,但对数字疫苗接种证书或新冠病毒阴性检测结果的强制要求有力地促进了接种。出于经济利益的雇主支持在促进遵守工作场所疫苗接种规定方面发挥了关键作用。事实证明,与非政府组织和社区伙伴的合作至关重要,提供了量身定制的健康宣传并建立了信任。灵活的疫苗接种策略,包括从集中模式转向在住所和工作场所附近的外展模式,增加了疫苗可及性,特别是对于难以接触到的人群。
尽管面临诸多挑战,但由于创新和协作的接种及沟通策略,马来西亚的疫苗接种工作在很大程度上取得了成功。为进一步改善边缘化人群的健康公平性,必须加强对一线工作人员的文化敏感培训,强化雇主的商业道德,并增加受信任利益相关者的参与。