Deal Anna, Hayward Sally E, Huda Mashal, Knights Felicity, Crawshaw Alison F, Carter Jessica, Hassan Osama B, Farah Yasmin, Ciftci Yusuf, Rowland-Pomp May, Rustage Kieran, Goldsmith Lucy, Hartmann Monika, Mounier-Jack Sandra, Burns Rachel, Miller Anna, Wurie Fatima, Campos-Matos Ines, Majeed Azeem, Hargreaves Sally
The Migrant Health Research Group, Institute for Infection and Immunity, St George's, University of London, UK.
Department of Public Health and Policy, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK.
J Migr Health. 2021;4:100050. doi: 10.1016/j.jmh.2021.100050. Epub 2021 May 27.
Early evidence confirms lower COVID-19 vaccine uptake in established ethnic minority populations, yet there has been little focus on understanding vaccine hesitancy and barriers to vaccination in migrants. Growing populations of precarious migrants (including undocumented migrants, asylum seekers and refugees) in the UK and Europe are considered to be under-immunised groups and may be excluded from health systems, yet little is known about their views on COVID-19 vaccines specifically, which are essential to identify key solutions and action points to strengthen vaccine roll-out.
We did an in-depth semi-structured qualitative interview study of recently arrived migrants (foreign-born, >18 years old; <10 years in the UK) to the UK with precarious immigration status between September 2020 and March 2021, seeking their input into strategies to strengthen COVID-19 vaccine delivery and uptake. We used the 'Three Cs' model (confidence, complacency and convenience) to explore COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy, barriers and access. Data were analysed using a thematic framework approach. Data collection continued until data saturation was reached, and no novel concepts were arising. The study was approved by the University of London ethics committee (REC 2020.00630).
We approached 20 migrant support groups nationwide, recruiting 32 migrants (mean age 37.1 years; 21 [66%] female; mean time in the UK 5.6 years [SD 3.7 years]), including refugees ( = 3), asylum seekers ( = 19), undocumented migrants ( = 8) and migrants with limited leave to remain ( = 2) from 15 different countries (5 WHO regions). 23 (72%) of 32 migrants reported being hesitant about accepting a COVID-19 vaccine and two (6%) would definitely not accept a vaccine. Participants communicated concerns over vaccine content, side-effects, lack of accessible information in an appropriate language, lack of trust in the health system and low perceived need. A range of barriers to accessing the COVID-19 vaccine were reported and concerns expressed that their communities would be excluded from or de-prioritised in the roll-out. Undocumented migrants described fears over being charged and facing immigration checks if they present for a vaccine. Participants ( = 10) interviewed after recent government announcements that COVID-19 vaccines can be accessed without facing immigration checks remained unaware of this. Participants stated that convenience of access would be a key factor in their decision around whether to accept a vaccine and proposed alternative access points to primary care services (for example, walk-in centres in trusted places such as foodbanks, community centres and charities), alongside promoting registration with primary care for all, and working closely with communities to produce accessible information on COVID-19 vaccination.
Precarious migrants may be hesitant about accepting a COVID-19 vaccine and face multiple and unique barriers to access, requiring simple but innovative solutions to ensure equitable access and uptake. Vaccine hesitancy and low awareness around entitlement and relevant access points could be easily addressed with clear, accessible, and tailored information campaigns, co-produced and delivered by trusted sources within marginalised migrant communities. These findings have immediate relevance to the COVID-19 vaccination initiatives in the UK and in other European and high-income countries with diverse migrant populations.
NIHR.
早期证据证实,在既定的少数族裔群体中,新冠疫苗接种率较低,但对于了解移民群体中疫苗犹豫情绪及接种障碍的关注却很少。英国和欧洲不稳定移民(包括无证移民、寻求庇护者和难民)数量不断增加,他们被视为免疫不足群体,可能被排除在卫生系统之外,然而对于他们对新冠疫苗的具体看法却知之甚少,而这对于确定加强疫苗推广的关键解决方案和行动要点至关重要。
2020年9月至2021年3月期间,我们对最近抵达英国、移民身份不稳定的移民(外国出生,年龄>18岁;在英国居住<10年)进行了深入的半结构化定性访谈研究,征求他们对加强新冠疫苗接种和推广策略的意见。我们使用“3C”模型(信心、自满和便利)来探讨新冠疫苗犹豫情绪、障碍和接种机会。采用主题框架法对数据进行分析。数据收集持续到达到数据饱和,不再有新的概念出现。该研究获得了伦敦大学伦理委员会的批准(研究伦理委员会编号2020.00630)。
我们联系了全国20个移民支持团体,招募了32名移民(平均年龄37.1岁;21名[66%]为女性;在英国的平均居住时间为5.6年[标准差3.7年]),包括来自15个不同国家(5个世卫组织区域)的难民(n = 3)、寻求庇护者(n = 19)、无证移民(n = 8)和有限期居留移民(n = 2)。32名移民中有23名(72%)表示对接受新冠疫苗犹豫不决,2名(6%)肯定不会接受疫苗。参与者表达了对疫苗成分、副作用、缺乏合适语言的可获取信息、对卫生系统缺乏信任以及较低的接种必要性认知等方面的担忧。报告了一系列获取新冠疫苗的障碍,并担心他们的社区在疫苗推广中会被排除在外或被置于次要地位。无证移民表示担心接种疫苗会被收费并面临移民检查。在政府最近宣布接种新冠疫苗无需面临移民检查后接受采访的参与者(n = 10)对此仍不知情。参与者表示,接种的便利性将是他们决定是否接受疫苗的关键因素,并提议设立替代的基层医疗服务接种点(例如,在食品银行、社区中心和慈善机构等受信任场所的无需预约诊所),同时推动所有人在基层医疗进行登记,并与社区密切合作,提供关于新冠疫苗接种的可获取信息。
不稳定移民可能对接受新冠疫苗犹豫不决,并面临多种独特的接种障碍,需要简单但创新的解决方案来确保公平接种和推广。通过由边缘化移民社区中受信任的来源共同制作并提供清晰、可获取且量身定制的宣传活动,可以轻松解决疫苗犹豫情绪以及对接种资格和相关接种点的低认知度问题。这些发现与英国以及其他拥有多样化移民人口的欧洲和高收入国家的新冠疫苗接种倡议直接相关。
英国国家卫生研究院。