Federico Maurizio
National Center for Global Health, Istituto Superiore di Sanità, 00161 Rome, Italy.
Int J Mol Sci. 2025 May 26;26(11):5118. doi: 10.3390/ijms26115118.
Self-amplifying RNA-based (saRNA) technology represents the last frontier in using synthetic RNA in vaccinology. Typically, saRNA consists of positive-strand RNA molecules of viral origin (almost exclusively from alphaviruses) where the sequences of structural proteins are replaced with the open reading frame coding the antigen of interest. For in vivo delivery, they are complexed with lipid nanoparticles (LNPs), just like current COVID-19 vaccines based on synthetic messenger RNA (mRNA). Given their ability to amplify themselves inside the cell, optimal intracellular levels of the immunogenic antigen can be achieved by delivering lower amounts of saRNA molecules compared to mRNA-based vaccines. However, the excessive intracellular accumulation of saRNA may represent a relevant drawback since, as already described in alphavirus-infected cells, the recipient cell may react by incorporating excessive RNA molecules into extracellular vesicles (EVs). These EVs can shed and enter neighboring as well as distant cells, where the EV-associated saRNA can start a new replication cycle. This mechanism could lead to an unwanted and unnecessary spread of saRNA throughout the body, posing relevant safety issues. This perspective article discusses the molecular mechanisms through which saRNAs can be transmitted among different cells/tissues. In addition, a simple way to control the possible excessive saRNA intercellular propagation through the co-expression of an EV-anchored protein inhibiting the saRNA replication is proposed. Based on current knowledge, a safety improvement of saRNA-based vaccines appears to be mandatory for their usage in healthy humans.
基于自我扩增RNA(saRNA)的技术代表了在疫苗学中使用合成RNA的最新前沿领域。通常,saRNA由病毒来源的正链RNA分子组成(几乎全部来自甲病毒),其中结构蛋白的序列被编码感兴趣抗原的开放阅读框所取代。对于体内递送,它们与脂质纳米颗粒(LNP)复合,就像目前基于合成信使RNA(mRNA)的新冠疫苗一样。鉴于它们在细胞内自我扩增的能力,与基于mRNA的疫苗相比,通过递送较少量的saRNA分子就可以实现免疫原性抗原在细胞内的最佳水平。然而,saRNA在细胞内的过度积累可能是一个相关的缺点,因为正如在甲病毒感染的细胞中已经描述的那样,受体细胞可能会通过将过多的RNA分子纳入细胞外囊泡(EV)来做出反应。这些EV可以脱落并进入邻近以及远处的细胞,并在其中与EV相关的saRNA可以开始新的复制周期。这种机制可能导致saRNA在全身不必要地传播,带来相关的安全问题。这篇观点文章讨论了saRNA在不同细胞/组织之间传播的分子机制。此外,还提出了一种简单的方法,即通过共表达一种抑制saRNA复制的锚定在EV上的蛋白质来控制可能过度的saRNA细胞间传播。基于目前的知识,对于基于saRNA的疫苗在健康人群中的使用,提高其安全性似乎是必不可少的。