Ng Mitchell K, Mont Michael A, Bonutti Peter M
Orthopedic Surgery, Maimonides Medical Center, Brooklyn, USA.
Orthopedic Surgery, LifeBridge Health, Baltimore, USA.
Cureus. 2025 May 13;17(5):e84022. doi: 10.7759/cureus.84022. eCollection 2025 May.
Quaternary ammonium compounds (QACs) are widely used disinfectants whose application expanded dramatically during the COVID-19 pandemic, raising concerns about long-term safety and environmental impact. This narrative review begins by outlining the chemical structure, mechanisms of action, and widespread use of QACs across healthcare, consumer, and industrial settings. We examine toxicologic findings from in vitro and animal studies, highlighting mitochondrial dysfunction, oxidative stress, and reproductive toxicity at low-dose exposures. Clinical and public health data are reviewed, linking QAC exposure to respiratory symptoms, dermatitis, and potential reproductive risks among healthcare workers and other vulnerable populations. Environmental harms are also discussed, including QAC persistence in soil and water, ecotoxicity in aquatic species, and potential for bioaccumulation. We then explore ultraviolet-C (UV-C) disinfection as a non-chemical alternative, demonstrating comparable antimicrobial efficacy without the toxicological or ecological drawbacks of QACs. Despite the growing use of QACs, few studies have comprehensively reviewed their adverse effects or evaluated UV-C as a viable substitute. This narrative review fills a critical gap by synthesizing current evidence across disciplines and highlighting the need for safer disinfection practices. We advocate for the broader adoption of UV-C technologies to reduce chemical exposure, protect public health, and promote environmental sustainability.
季铵化合物(QACs)是广泛使用的消毒剂,在新冠疫情期间其应用急剧增加,这引发了人们对其长期安全性和环境影响的担忧。本叙述性综述首先概述了QACs的化学结构、作用机制,以及它们在医疗保健、消费和工业环境中的广泛应用。我们研究了体外和动物研究的毒理学发现,强调了低剂量暴露下的线粒体功能障碍、氧化应激和生殖毒性。对临床和公共卫生数据进行了综述,将QAC暴露与医护人员和其他弱势群体的呼吸道症状、皮炎以及潜在的生殖风险联系起来。还讨论了环境危害,包括QACs在土壤和水中的持久性、对水生物种的生态毒性以及生物累积的可能性。然后,我们探讨了紫外线-C(UV-C)消毒作为一种非化学替代方法,证明其具有可比的抗菌效果,且没有QACs的毒理学或生态学缺点。尽管QACs的使用越来越多,但很少有研究全面综述其不良反应或评估UV-C作为一种可行替代品的情况。本叙述性综述通过综合各学科的现有证据并强调需要更安全的消毒做法,填补了一个关键空白。我们主张更广泛地采用UV-C技术,以减少化学物质暴露、保护公众健康并促进环境可持续性。