Choi Changhyun, Kim Hongrae, Sohn Dae Kyung
Biomedical Engineering Branch, Research Institute and Hospital, National Cancer Center, Goyang, Korea.
Center for Colorectal Cancer, National Cancer Center, Goyang, Korea.
J Minim Invasive Surg. 2025 Jun 15;28(2):51-61. doi: 10.7602/jmis.2025.28.2.51.
Virtual reality (VR) has emerged as a transformative tool in surgical education, offering a controlled and repeatable training environment that mitigates ethical and legal challenges associated with traditional apprenticeship models. By simulating real-life surgical scenarios, VR allows trainees to practice procedures safely while improving skill acquisition and procedural efficiency. In this study, we systematically reviewed research trends in VR-based surgical education to provide insights into its current applications and future potential.
A comprehensive literature search was conducted on PubMed, identifying 395 studies. Of these, 92 studies met predefined inclusion criteria and were selected for analysis. The selected studies were analyzed based on publication period, surgical procedure, medical specialty, country of origin, and outcome measures.
Study findings revealed that research on VR surgical simulation peaked between 2005 and 2009, followed by a decline in recent years. Laparoscopic and endoscopic training were the most frequently studied procedures, with general surgery and gastroenterology being the most predominant specialties. The United States contributed the highest number of publications. Common outcome measures for evaluating VR training effectiveness included time, movement economy, subject evaluation, error rates, proficiency scales, and accuracy.
These findings illustrate the historical trajectory and current landscape of VR use in surgical training. While the initial surge in interest has waned, VR remains a valuable tool for procedural skill development, particularly in laparoscopic and endoscopic training, and its future potential may depend on improvements in realism, cost-efficiency, and curriculum integration.
虚拟现实(VR)已成为外科教育中的一种变革性工具,提供了一个可控且可重复的培训环境,减轻了与传统学徒模式相关的伦理和法律挑战。通过模拟现实生活中的手术场景,VR使受训人员能够安全地练习手术操作,同时提高技能掌握程度和手术效率。在本研究中,我们系统地回顾了基于VR的外科教育的研究趋势,以深入了解其当前应用和未来潜力。
在PubMed上进行了全面的文献检索,共识别出395项研究。其中,92项研究符合预定义的纳入标准并被选作分析对象。所选研究根据发表时间、手术操作、医学专科、原产国和结果指标进行分析。
研究结果显示,VR手术模拟的研究在2005年至2009年间达到顶峰,近年来有所下降。腹腔镜和内镜培训是研究最频繁的手术操作,普通外科和胃肠病学是最主要的专科。美国的出版物数量最多。评估VR培训效果的常见结果指标包括时间、动作经济性、受试者评估、错误率、熟练程度量表和准确性。
这些发现说明了VR在外科培训中的历史轨迹和当前状况。虽然最初的兴趣热潮已经消退,但VR仍然是程序技能发展的宝贵工具,特别是在腹腔镜和内镜培训方面,其未来潜力可能取决于在真实感、成本效益和课程整合方面的改进。