Pérez de Los Cobos Cintas Clara, Vuillerme Nicolas, Thomann Guillaume, Di Marco Lionel
Laboratoire des Sciences pour la Conception, l'Optimisation et la Production, 46 Av. Félix Viallet, Grenoble, 38000, France, 33 04 76 57 50 71.
Autonomie, Gérontologie, E-santé, Imagerie et Société, 2Univ.Grenoble Alpes, AGEIS, Grenoble, France.
JMIR Nurs. 2025 Jun 18;8:e68984. doi: 10.2196/68984.
BACKGROUND: Midwifery students often experience anxiety due to several factors, such as the clinical experiences faced. Simulation-based learning in nursing and midwifery studies using extended reality (XR) tools offers the opportunity to manage better educational processes while reducing this anxiety. OBJECTIVE: This study aims to evaluate the current knowledge and understanding of how the use of XR gesture-simulation-based tools allows a better understanding of the anxiety levels of midwives and nurses in educational settings. METHODS: We conducted a systematic review, a scientific literature search following the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines. Using PubMed, IEEE, Scopus, and Web of Science, up to March 2024, 1005 articles were found to identify studies that reported the effectiveness of these technologies for gesture simulation in education and training on nursing and midwifery student anxiety. The inclusion-exclusion criteria were based on the PICO (population, intervention, control, and outcomes) framework. The population included nurses, midwives, and nursing and midwifery students of any kind using any virtual or augmented or mixed reality simulation training tool to perform a procedure aimed at reducing anxiety. In addition, the Cochrane risk of bias tool was used to evaluate the quality of the systematic review and the bias in the included studies. A narrative synthesis was conducted due to the heterogeneity of study designs and outcome measures. Key findings were summarized in a structured table and grouped according to the learning objective, simulating and performing procedures in an educational setting. RESULTS: Overall, 7 articles, involving a total of 428 participants, were included in this review. The findings indicate that XR can effectively reduce anxiety in midwifery and nursing education. However, the limited number of studies highlights a research gap in the field, particularly in the area of mixed reality, which warrants further exploration. CONCLUSIONS: This systematic review highlights the potential of XR-based gesture-simulation tools in reducing anxiety among midwifery and nursing students. The included studies suggest that XR-enhanced training provides a more immersive and controlled learning environment, helping students manage stress and improve procedural confidence. However, the limited number of studies, methodological variations, and the underrepresentation of mixed reality applications indicate the need for further research. Future studies should focus on standardized anxiety measurement tools, larger sample sizes, and long-term impact assessments to strengthen the evidence base. Expanding research in this field could enhance the integration of XR technologies into midwifery and nursing education, ultimately improving both learning experiences and clinical preparedness.
背景:助产专业学生常因多种因素而感到焦虑,比如所面临的临床经历。护理和助产专业学习中使用扩展现实(XR)工具进行基于模拟的学习,为更好地管理教育过程提供了机会,同时也能减轻这种焦虑。 目的:本研究旨在评估当前对于使用基于XR手势模拟的工具如何能更好地了解教育环境中助产士和护士焦虑水平的认识和理解。 方法:我们按照PRISMA(系统评价和Meta分析的首选报告项目)指南进行了系统评价和科学文献检索。利用PubMed、IEEE、Scopus和科学网,截至2024年3月,共找到1005篇文章,以确定报告这些技术在护理和助产专业学生焦虑的教育培训中进行手势模拟有效性的研究。纳入和排除标准基于PICO(人群、干预措施、对照和结局)框架。人群包括使用任何虚拟、增强或混合现实模拟培训工具来执行旨在减轻焦虑的程序的护士、助产士以及各类护理和助产专业学生。此外,使用Cochrane偏倚风险工具来评估系统评价的质量以及纳入研究中的偏倚。由于研究设计和结局测量的异质性,进行了叙述性综合分析。关键发现总结在一个结构化表格中,并根据学习目标进行分组,即在教育环境中模拟和执行程序。 结果:总体而言,本综述纳入了7篇文章,共涉及428名参与者。研究结果表明,XR能有效减轻助产和护理教育中的焦虑。然而,研究数量有限凸显了该领域的研究空白,尤其是在混合现实领域,这值得进一步探索。 结论:本系统评价突出了基于XR的手势模拟工具在减轻助产和护理专业学生焦虑方面的潜力。纳入的研究表明,XR增强培训提供了更具沉浸感和可控性的学习环境,有助于学生应对压力并提高操作信心。然而,研究数量有限、方法学差异以及混合现实应用的代表性不足表明需要进一步研究。未来的研究应专注于标准化的焦虑测量工具、更大的样本量以及长期影响评估,以加强证据基础。扩大该领域的研究可以促进XR技术融入助产和护理教育,最终改善学习体验和临床准备情况。
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2016-4
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2015-8-14
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2017-11
Midwifery. 2024-12
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2021-8-12
Nurse Educ Today. 2021-7